HomeFeaturesExamplesTutorialsHelpTheoryVerificationPricingContact
BoreTherm / TutorialsTutorial 12 / 19
Workflow and theory · Costs & comparison

Heating-system comparison

How BoreTherm compares the borefield heat pump with an air/water heat pump, boilers, district heating and a hybrid on the same service; how it calculates energy, SPF, the annual full cost and CO₂; and how the ground-source variant uses the project’s heat pump. The example project is a small office building (about 3000 m²) with 200 MWh/year space heating, 8 MWh/year hot water and 45 MWh/year cooling (monthly loads) on a 4 × 4 field of 16 boreholes of 150 m, simulated over 25 years. The same building with a temperature-dependent heat pump and the borehole length sized for it is a second example project.

01 / The one idea

The one idea: the same service, priced over the whole period

Every enabled variant must deliver the same useful heat, hot water and cold to the building. Each one needs a different amount of final energy for it, and each one has a different investment, service life and maintenance. BoreTherm turns all of it into one number per variant: the annual full cost, the annuity of all discounted cash flows over the period (VDI 2067 style).

Same serviceheat 208 MWh/a(DHW 8 MWh/a)cold 45 MWh/apeak 102 kWGround-source HPelectricityAir/water HPelectricityGas boilergas (+ chiller)Oil boileroil (+ chiller)Pellet boilerpellets (+ chiller)District heatingdistrict heat (+ chiller)Hybrid air HP + gaselectricity + gasCash flows over T yearsinvestment and replacementsenergy, operation− grant, − residual valuediscounted: NPVannual full cost = a · NPVEcology (annual)CO₂ statutory and estimateprimary energyEvery variant gets the same heat, hot water and cold; a variant without cooling gets a chiller.
The service comes from the building loads of the project. The borefield variant is priced with the estimate of Economics › Borefield costs; the other plants with cost curves of the data set.
Annuity factora = i / (1 − (1 + i)−T)
Annual full costA = a · Σ CFt (1 + i)−t
Levelised cost of heatLCOH = (A − Acold) / Qheat
SPF; Wel: compressor, backup heater, source pumpSPF = Qheat / Wel
Boiler, district heatingfuel = Qheat / η

Terms: i interest rate, T period in years, CFt cash flow of year t, NPV net present value (the sum of the discounted cash flows). COP (coefficient of performance): heat / electricity of a heat pump at one operating point; SPF (seasonal performance factor): the same over the year; SEER and EER: cold / electricity over the year and at one point; η: efficiency of a boiler or a district-heating substation. JAZ: the seasonal performance factor after the guideline VDI 4650; B0/W35: brine 0 °C, heating water 35 °C. DHW: domestic hot water. BHE (borehole heat exchanger): the ground-source variant.

What decides the result. A ground-source system pays more at the start and less for energy every year. Whether that pays off depends on the period, the interest rate, the tariffs, the maintenance and the residual value of the long-lived borefield, not on the SPF alone. A borefield can lose the comparison: in the example below the air/water heat pump is cheaper.
02 / The workflow

The workflow

The comparison needs building loads. Before it starts, decide on Design › Heat pump › Setup how the heat pump enters the borefield calculation; that also decides which heat pump the ground-source variant uses. The comparison is calculated with Calculation › Calculate.

Building loads on the Loads pagemonthly or hourly: heat, DHW, coolingDesign › Heat pump › Setup:how is heat pump performance calculated?fixed seasonaltemperature-dependentGround-source variant: its own modelCOP from the variant’s datasheet points(default: generic B0/W35 4.5), at thesimulated field outlet temperature;the field was simulated with the fixedSPF (a warning says so)Ground-source variant: the project’sheat pump model (Setup) in the coupledloop; COP and ground loads agree;the comparison’s synthetic climatereplaces the model’s outdoor climatewhile the comparison is includedThe other six variants are the same in both casesDirect ground loads or time series cannot be compared: the building service is unknown.
With fixed seasonal efficiency the borefield temperatures and the comparison’s electricity come from two different heat pump assumptions. The temperature-dependent mode makes them agree.
Loadsbuilding heat,DHW, coolingHeat pump› Setup: modeand modelBorefield costsnet total =field investmentHeating-systemcomparison: period,interest, variantsCalculateor the button“Calculatecomparison”Results › System comparisonheadline table, annuity andcumulative charts, CO₂,energy, criteria, dataReportsection System comparison(client summary profile)Further questionsEconomic tornado (sensitivity)LCOH and SPF versus lengthOptimize, objective Life-cycle costinputs (navigation tree)buttons on the comparison pageresults
The comparison page is under Economics; its results are under Results. The comparison runs with every Calculate while it is included. Calculation › Optimize can use the life-cycle cost as its objective.
  1. Borefield costs: check the estimate. Its net total is the borefield investment (service life 50 years); it is recalculated from the current design every time, so a different length changes the investment.
  2. Heating-system comparison: tick Include system comparison when calculating; set the period, interest, gross or net prices, residual value, KfW grant estimate, CO₂ price scenario and synthetic climate. The variant table holds the net equipment investment, life, COP or efficiency, auxiliary electricity, operation and the chiller SEER of each variant; Advanced assumptions… shows the full specification (heat pump models, tariffs, grants, cooling allocation). Every datum of the data set carries its value, unit, validity dates, source and status.
  3. Enter qualitative scores and knock-outs if needed (noise, space, permits, drilling risk, price exposure). A knock-out removes a variant from the lowest-cost marker; scores never change the costs.
  4. Calculate (Calculation › Calculate or the button Calculate comparison) and read Results › System comparison with its warnings. Economic tornado and LCOH and SPF versus length answer the next questions.
03 / How the calculation works

How the calculation works

1 Service profilemonthly loads → hourly(load generator); syntheticoutdoor temperature2 Energy per variantBHE: field + heat pumpair: hourly COP, capacityboilers: heat / efficiency3 Final energyper carrier: electricity,gas, oil, pellets,district heat4 Componentsplant a · P^b at peak, extras,chiller, borefield = Costs× (1 + VAT) if gross8 Rankingcheapest = lowest annualfull cost (not knocked out);break-even year7 Per kWh and ecologyLCOH heat, heat + cold,cost of cold; CO₂, primaryenergy; VDI 4650 JAZ6 NPV and annuitydiscounted at i; a · NPV,per cost group; low andhigh CO₂ price scenarios5 Cash flowsinvest t = 0, replace at k L,energy, operation t = 1..T,grant t = 0, residual t = Ttechnical: the same service for every enabled varianteconomic: VDI 2067-style annuity from explicit discounted cash flows
Steps 1–3 give the energy of each variant, steps 4–6 its cost, steps 7–8 the per-kWh values, ecology and ranking. The low and high CO₂ scenarios repeat steps 5–6.

Ground-source variant. BoreTherm uses the borefield simulation of the project. If the variant’s cooling differs from the design (passive instead of active cooling, or a separate chiller), the borefield is simulated again for that cooling. Month by month (hour by hour with hourly loads) the heat pump sees the brine leaving the field, Tout = Tf − Q / (2 ṁ cp) (Tf: mean fluid temperature of the borehole, the mean of inlet and outlet; Q: heat taken from the ground; ṁ cp: mass flow × specific heat of the brine), as its source and the heating-curve flow temperature (domestic hot water: its own temperature) as its sink. The COP comes from the heat pump model; load above the capacity, or brine below the minimum source temperature, goes to an electric backup at COP 1. The source pump runs its hours. Passive cooling is used while the brine for the peak injection case stays at or below the passive limit (16 °C by default); above it the machine cools actively with its EER.

Air/water and hybrid. Hour by hour from the synthetic outdoor temperature: COP(outdoor, flow), the capacity of the machine, hot water first, backup heater for the rest. Below the bivalence point (−3 °C by default) the hybrid’s gas boiler covers what its heat pump cannot. Boilers and district heating need heat / η of fuel plus auxiliary electricity. A variant that cannot cool gets an air-cooled chiller (SEER 3.5) so the service stays equal.

04 / The theory behind the result

The theory behind the result

Climate, heating curve and COP

The comparison does not use measured weather. It builds a seeded synthetic year: a seasonal cosine around the mean of the climate preset, a daily cycle (± 4 K, warmest at 15 h) and an autocorrelated day-to-day weather (σ 3 K). The heating curve gives the flow temperature from the outdoor temperature, linear between the heating limit (flow = return temperature) and the design outdoor temperature (flow = design flow temperature).

Synthetic outdoor temperature (seasonal part)091182273365−20−1001020day of the operating year°Cdesign −12 °Cheating limit 15 °CDE-central: 10 ± 9 KDE-cold: 7 ± 11 KCOP at W35: default models of the variants−15−10−505101512345678source temperature: brine or outdoor air [°C]COPbrine min. 1.0 °C: 4.6air at −12 °C: 2.4ground sourceair source
Left: the seasonal part of the synthetic outdoor temperature. Right: the default COP models along W35, a heating flow of 35 °C (datasheet points × Carnot). The air source is coldest when the heat is needed most; the brine stays near its lowest monthly value.

Cash flows and the annual full cost

Investments are paid at t = 0 and again after each service life inside the period; energy and operation at the end of every year t = 1…T; a grant at t = 0; the residual value of the last installation (its unused linear life) is credited at t = T. Every amount is discounted at its own time, summed to the NPV and turned into the annual full cost with the annuity factor a. Each cost group gets its own annuity, which is what the chart below shows. Prices are real (EUR 2026) unless you choose nominal prices and enter consistent paths.

Annual full cost by cost group [€/a]: credits to the left of zerocapitalenergyoperationresidual value−10k0k10k20k30k40k50kGround-source HP34,154Air/water HP31,734 ✓ lowestGas boiler40,299Oil boiler45,292Pellet boiler35,502District heating41,036Hybrid air HP + gas40,269
The example, 20 years at 2 %, gross prices. Capital is the largest part for the heat pumps, energy for the boilers. The borefield’s long life (50 years) returns as residual value.
Cumulative discounted cost [k€]202520302035204020450100200300400500600700year (first row: the investment)k€Ground-source HPAir/water HPGas boilerPellet boilerDistrict heatingfrom 2042 the ground-sourcesystem stays below gas
Steps up are replacements (air/water heat pump after 18 years, pellet boiler after 15), the drop in the last year is the residual value. A break-even year counts only if the ground-source system stays cheaper to the end; it is not a simple payback.
05 / How each result is derived

How each result is derived

Ground-source variant of the example (office, 16 × 150 m, fixed SPF mode, passive cooling), data set DE 2026-10 (2026-10-18), gross, real prices, EUR.

ResultHow BoreTherm derives itExample
Useful heat and coldbuilding loads; monthly loads are spread over hours with the load generator; multiyear loads are averagedheat 208,000 kWh/a (DHW 8,000), cold 45,000 kWh/a
Ground-source electricitymonth by month: COP(field outlet, heating-curve flow), capacity share, backup at COP 1, source pump; passive cooling: the pump onlyheating 44,605 kWh/a (pump 13,363 in total), cooling 7,297 kWh/a
SPF, SEERheat / heating electricity (with backup and source pump); cold / cooling electricitySPF 4.66, SEER 6.17
JAZ after VDI 4650COPB0/W35 · FΔϑ · Fϑ / FP, hot water by eq. 5, overall eq. 13; ϑB,min = lowest monthly field outlet4.53 (ϑB,min 0.98 °C, FP 1.134)
Investmentplant a · Pb at the peak (without the borehole source) + extras + borefield = the net total of Borefield costs; × (1 + VAT) for gross prices(60,834 + 41,332 + 131,200) × 1.19 = 277,705 €
Energy costkWh × tariff of the carrier each year (+ CO₂ charge for gas and oil)51,902 kWh × 0.28 €/kWh = 14,533 €/a
Operationinvestment × (fInst + fW+Insp) + hours × labour rate (residential: 0 €/h)6,494 €/a, constant in real prices: annuity 6,494 €/a
Residual valueunused linear life of the last installation, credited at t = Tborefield 156,128 × (50 − 20) / 50 = 93,677 € → −3,855 €/a
Annual full costa · NPV, a = i / (1 − (1 + i)−T)a = 0.0612 (i = 2 %, T = 20 a): 34,154 €/a
LCOHheat: (A − cooling share) / heat; heat + cold: A / (heat + cold); cold: cooling share / cold15.4 / 13.5 / 4.5 ct/kWh
CO₂ and primary energykWh × factor of the carrier at the data date (statutory GModG Anlage 9 / 4; estimate: direct CO₂)29.1 t/a statutory, 17.9 t/a estimate, 93 MWh/a
Break-even yearfirst year after which the discounted cumulative cost of the BHE stays below the other variantgas 2042, air/water: none
06 / The example in numbers

The example in numbers

VariantInvestment [€]Annual full cost [€/a]LCOH heat [ct/kWh]SPF (heat pump) or ηCO₂ stat. [t/a]BHE cheaper from
Ground-source HP277,70534,15415.44.6629.1—
Air/water HP187,69031,73413.74.4532.5never
Gas boiler65,94140,29916.60.9654.22042
Oil boiler78,38345,29219.00.9376.62039
Pellet boiler133,78535,50214.30.9012.02045
District heating59,30041,03616.90.9845.52040
Hybrid air HP + gas247,39540,26916.6—36.92039

In this example the air/water heat pump has the lowest annual full cost; the ground-source system costs 2,421 €/a more. By cost group, ground-source minus air/water heat pump [€/a]: capital +17, energy −1,719, operation +3,290, residual value +833. The largest difference is operation: the data set gives the borefield VDI 2067 repair and servicing of 3 % of its investment per year (4,684 €/a here). The ground-source system has the lower energy cost and CO₂ and beats gas, oil, pellets, district heating and the hybrid within the period. The default tariffs and plant costs are illustrative (status “assumption”): replace them, and review the borefield’s operation fractions, before you draw a conclusion.

Fixed SPF or the project’s heat pump

Ground-source variantFixed seasonal efficiencyTemperature-dependent
Projectoffice_4x4_exampleheat_pump_office_solution
Heat pump in the calculationfixed SPF on Setup; the variant’s generic modeltemperature-dependent; Beta 60 × 2 (Setup)
Borehole length, borefield net total150 m, 131,200 €160.0 m, 138,415 €
Coupling passesnone (one pass)3, converged yes
SPF (simulated) / JAZ (VDI 4650)4.66 / 4.534.71 / 5.13
Electricity [kWh/a]51,90251,984
Annual full cost34,154 €/a34,748 €/a

In the temperature-dependent case the ground-source variant uses the project’s heat pump (here Beta 60 × 2, 120 kW, minimum brine −8 °C, EER 5.6) and the borefield sized for it. The plant investment of the variant stays the cost curve of the data set; enter the quotation of the machine in the variant table.

07 / Limits to keep in mind

Limits to keep in mind

  • The climate is synthetic (DE-central: mean 10 °C, amplitude 9 K, design −12 °C), not a test reference year. It drives the air/water COP and the heating curve of every heat pump.
  • Default tariffs, plant costs, chiller and district-heating data are illustrative; the data set flags each value with its status and date, and warns when values expire or are older than six months.
  • The simulated SPF includes compressor, backup and source pump; it is not the VDI 4650 JAZ, which BoreTherm reports beside it. With monthly loads the brine minimum of the JAZ is a monthly mean (VDI 4650 suggests a weekly mean).
  • In the temperature-dependent mode the project’s heat pump model must have a realistic capacity (Setup): a model with small datasheet capacities sends most of the heat to the backup heater and the SPF collapses.
  • With fixed seasonal efficiency the borefield temperatures and the comparison’s COP come from different assumptions (a warning says so).
  • Grants are off by default; the automatic KfW estimate does not check eligibility. Ecological values are annual values at the data date, not lifetime forecasts; the CO₂ price scenarios change only the variants that burn gas or oil.
  • The comparison covers one building. Landlord cost splits, tax credits, refrigerant leakage and DWD weather files are not modelled.

Numbers calculated with BoreTherm. Calculated with boretherm-cli compare. Indicative comparison, not a binding offer.