Methods, references & limitations

Proof you can inspect.

Explore the reference comparisons, model conventions and published methods behind BoreTherm’s engineering calculations.

Largest monthly difference
0.130 K

Month-end mean fluid temperature, base and peak loads, against an independent open-source sizing tool.

Same inputs, same conventionsDifferences stated, not hidden

Evidence has a scope.
And a date.

Each comparison below names the kind of reference, the quantity compared and the largest difference found. The worked examples were recalculated with BoreTherm in October 2026.

Agreement with a reference shows that the method is implemented as published. It does not replace a review of the inputs of a real project.

Independent reference comparisons

The reported agreement.

ReferenceCompared quantityReported agreement
Independent software
Open-source g-function libraryg-functions, 10 layouts, all exact methods5·10⁻¹¹
Open-source sizing toolMonth-end mean fluid temperature, base and peak≤ 0.130 K
Open-source sizing toolHourly fluid temperature≤ 0.016 K
Open-source sizing toolRequired borehole length≤ 0.06 %
Published results
Published software manual, worked example48 monthly temperatures · required length0.15 K · 0.3 %
Published software reference valuesRb* against flow rate≤ 0.09 %
Ahmadfard & Bernier [9]Seven inter-model sizing cases≤ 1.3 %
Beier et al. [4]TRT conductivity, laboratory sandbox1.8 %
Design handbooks: Kavanaugh & Rafferty, Chiasson, Bonin, Laloui & Rotta LoriaNine worked examples: borehole resistance, pump head, heat pump selection, required length, energy pileRb (single U) ≤ 0.4 % · pump head ≤ 1.9 % where the book calculates the loop loss · lengths −12 % to +10 % against the handbook design equations; every difference explained per example
Independent numerics
Finite-volume solutionLayered g-function, two / three layers0.58 % / 2.23 %
Time-domain evaluationMoving finite line source (groundwater)4·10⁻¹²
Point-source quadratureInclined boreholes10⁻¹⁴
Stehfest-inverted analytic solutionShort-time radial borehole model2.6·10⁻⁴
Synthetic TRTRecovered λ · Rb*1 % · 2 %
The model chain

Trace the answer
back to the method.

Ground response

Finite-line-source g-functions describe borefield interaction. Ground layers, temperature gradients and groundwater assumptions set the context.

Borehole and fluid

Multipole borehole resistance, convection and flow calculations connect the ground response to fluid temperatures and pressure loss.

Loads and time

Monthly base and peak loads, or hourly series, are superposed over the design horizon. Peak and aggregation conventions matter.

Design decision

Sizing searches for the length that meets the stated limits. Studies, uncertainty and higher-detail models explore how assumptions change that result.

Read further

References and interpretation.

Scientific publications behind the workflow

These publications provide methods and reference data. They do not certify every implementation or design that uses them.

  1. Thermal analysis of heat extraction boreholes ↗

    Eskilson, P. (1987). Doctoral thesis, Lund University.

    Long-term ground response and g-functions.

  2. A semi-analytical method to generate g-functions for geothermal bore fields ↗

    Cimmino, M. & Bernier, M. (2014). International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 70, 641–650.

    Finite-line-source segmentation and borefield interaction.

  3. Multipole method to calculate borehole thermal resistances in a borehole heat exchanger ↗

    Claesson, J. & Hellström, G. (2011). HVAC&R Research, 17(6), 895–911.

    Borehole thermal resistance and internal heat transfer.

  4. Reference data sets for vertical borehole ground heat exchanger models and thermal response test analysis ↗

    Beier, R.A., Smith, M.D. & Spitler, J.D. (2011). Geothermics, 40(1), 79–85.

    Measured laboratory TRT with independent material properties (example 06).

  5. Thermal interactions in large irregular fields of geothermal boreholes: the method of equivalent boreholes ↗

    Prieto, C. & Cimmino, M. (2021). Journal of Building Performance Simulation, 14(4), 446–460.

    Equivalent-borehole clustering for large fields.

  6. A computationally efficient hybrid time step methodology for simulation of ground heat exchangers ↗

    Cullin, J.R. & Spitler, J.D. (2011). Geothermics, 40(2), 144–156.

    Time discretisation and load aggregation.

  7. Finite element modeling of borehole heat exchanger systems: Part 1. Fundamentals ↗

    Diersch, H.-J.G., Bauer, D., Heidemann, W., Rühaak, W. & Schätzl, P. (2011). Computers & Geosciences, 37(8), 1122–1135.

    Coupled formation and borehole heat exchanger equations.

  8. Modelling system integrated borehole heat exchanger fields – a comparison of simplified models and co-simulation

    Kirschstein, X., Ohagen, M., Reber, J., Sass, I. & Hübler, C. (2025). European Geothermal Congress.

    Measured-case comparison of simplified borefield models and co-simulation.

  9. A review of vertical ground heat exchanger sizing tools including an inter-model comparison ↗

    Ahmadfard, M. & Bernier, M. (2019). Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 110, 247–265.

    Inter-model sizing cases used for validation.

What does “within 0.130 K” mean?

It is the reported maximum difference for the specified cases of the open-source sizing tool after matching the documented comparison conventions. It is not an uncertainty bound on a real site, where ground and load assumptions also affect the result.

How should I use the worked examples?

Read the project description and input assumptions, then compare the results and design variants on the example page. Use the discussion and warning log to identify what the model does and does not establish.

Browse the 23 worked examples ↗

What still needs project-specific engineering review?

Ground properties, hydraulic assumptions, boundary and mesh choices, temperature limits and operating loads must suit the project. A qualified engineer must review a real design, including site and permitting requirements.

BoreTherm