HomeFeaturesExamplesTutorialsHelpTheoryVerificationPricingContact
BoreTherm / Example libraryExample 09 / 23
Worked feature example

Layout optimization

Search feasible office field layouts under the installed optimization settings. Compare ranking by total length, installation cost and lifecycle cost.

16Boreholes
-2.41 °CMinimum mean fluid temperature
16.03 °CMaximum mean fluid temperature
4Variants compared
01 / Project

What the example does

On a 40 m × 30 m plot, BoreTherm searches for the best field for the office building: line, L-shape, U-shape, open rectangle and rectangle, 4 to 40 boreholes, spacing 5 to 12 m, depth 60 to 250 m. Three objectives are compared: the shortest total length, the lowest installation cost and the lowest life-cycle cost.

Inputs

InputValue
Field16 boreholes, 4 × 4 rectangle, spacing 6.0 × 6.0 m
Boreholeslength 150.0 m, top 4.0 m below the surface, diameter 140 mm
Constructionsingle U, PE pipe 32 × 2.9 mm, shank spacing 70 mm, grout 1.60 W/(m·K)
Groundthermal conductivity 2.60 W/(m·K), heat capacity 2.20 MJ/(m³·K), surface temperature 9.0 °C, geothermal heat flux 0.060 W/m²
Fluid and flow25 % monopropylene glycol, 0.50 l/s per borehole
Loadsmonthly: heating 200 MWh, hot water 8 MWh and cooling 45 MWh per year; peaks 100 kW heating and 45 kW cooling for 6 h
Heat pumpseasonal performance factors 3.8 heating, 2.8 hot water, 5.0 cooling
Design limitsmean fluid temperature between −3.0 °C and 20.0 °C
Period25 years
Plot40 m × 30 m
Search5 layout types, 4–40 boreholes, spacing 5–12 m, depth 60–250 m
Costs5,000 EUR fixed, 800 EUR per borehole, 45 EUR/m drilling, 60 EUR/m trench

Run the example in BoreTherm

  1. Press Optimize. In the dialog, set the plot, the layout types, the ranges and the objective.
  2. Run the search. Results → Optimization candidates lists the best layouts, best first, with their plan.
  3. Select a candidate and apply it to the project, then calculate it again.
02 / How BoreTherm calculates it

How Optimize searches the plot

1 Candidatesevery layout type, count andspacing that fits the plot2 Size eachrequired length H for thelimits (as Size borehole length)3 Feasible?H within 60–250 m;clearances on the plot4 Costfixed + per borehole + drilling+ trench (+ operation)5 Rankby total length, cost orlife-cycle cost6 Keep the best20 candidates with planand key figuresBest by cost: 12 boreholes, 8 m spacing, 164 m
Every candidate is sized; the objective decides only the ranking.
  1. CandidatesBoreTherm generates all layouts of the selected types that fit on the plot.
  2. Size eachEach candidate gets the length that just meets the limits.
  3. Feasible?Candidates outside the depth range are dropped.
  4. CostThe cost model adds the fixed cost, the boreholes, the drilled metres and the trench.
  5. RankTotal length and installation cost lead to the same field here. The life-cycle cost adds the energy of the heat pump over the years and prefers a longer field (180.5 m) with warmer fluid and a better efficiency.
  6. Keep the bestThe candidates are proposals; none is applied automatically.
03 / In BoreTherm

The example in BoreTherm

The Optimize dialog: plot, layout types, ranges and objective.
The Optimize dialog: plot, layout types, ranges and objective.
Results → Optimization candidates: the ranked layouts.
Results → Optimization candidates: the ranked layouts.
04 / Results

Calculated results

Calculated with BoreTherm for every variant of the example. Displayed values are rounded.

ObjectiveRetainedLayoutCountSpacing [m]H [m]Total [m]Install net [EUR]LCOH [EUR/kWh]
TotalLength9Rectangle128.000164.0131,968.157108,447.05—
TotalCost9Rectangle128.000164.0131,968.157108,447.05—
LifeCycleCost9Rectangle128.000180.5282,166.338117,365.210.1476
Layout optimization results plotted from BoreTherm output
Chart of the BoreTherm results in the tables of this section.

Temperatures by variant

VariantBoreholesLength H [m]Tf min [°C]Tf max [°C]Rb* [m K/W]Pump [W]Design limits
input design16150.000-2.41316.0260.11943,033.2within limits
best by life-cycle cost16150.000-2.41316.0260.11943,033.2within limits
best by cost16150.000-2.41316.0260.11943,033.2within limits
best by length16150.000-2.41316.0260.11943,033.2within limits
05 / Discussion

What the example shows

Under these assumptions a 12-borehole rectangle at 8 m spacing is best by length and by installation cost (1,968 m, about 108,000 EUR). The life-cycle objective chooses longer boreholes, because a warmer source saves heat pump electricity over 20 years.

The feasible set is limited by the plot, the counts, the spacing and the depth range. Cost figures are estimates from the project's unit rates; the life-cycle objective uses the heating-system comparison data of the project.