HomeFeaturesExamplesTutorialsHelpTheoryVerificationPricingContact
BoreTherm / Example libraryExample 15 / 23
Worked feature example

3D and FEM analysis

A 40 m borehole in an aquifer demonstrates mesh-based thermal analysis, background groundwater flow, coupled heat and flow, transient boreholes and 3D sizing.

1Boreholes
-5.25 °CMinimum mean fluid temperature
-2.69 °CMaximum mean fluid temperature
3Variants compared
01 / Project

What the example does

One 40 m borehole in an aquifer with groundwater flow feeds a heat pump. The 2D design method, the 3D finite-element model of the ground and the fully coupled heat and groundwater model are compared, and the borehole is sized in 2D and in 3D.

Inputs

InputValue
Field1 borehole, free positions
Boreholeslength 40.0 m, top 4.0 m below the surface, diameter 110 mm
Constructionsingle U, PE pipe 32 × 2.9 mm, shank spacing 70 mm, grout 1.60 W/(m·K)
Groundthermal conductivity 2.60 W/(m·K), heat capacity 2.20 MJ/(m³·K), surface temperature 9.0 °C, geothermal heat flux 0.060 W/m²
Fluid and flow25 % monopropylene glycol, 0.50 l/s per borehole
Loadsmonthly: heating 13 MWh, hot water 0 MWh and cooling 0 MWh per year; peaks 0 kW heating and 0 kW cooling
Design limitsmean fluid temperature between 2.0 °C and 30.0 °C
Period1 year
Models2D analytic; 3D analysis (FEM, conduction); full FEM with coupled heat and groundwater flow; transient boreholes with a pump stop

Run the example in BoreTherm

  1. Open Advanced analysis → 3D / Full FEM → Full FEM → Physics & run. Choose the physics (conduction, groundwater flow, coupled), the mesh and the time step.
  2. Check Full FEM → Materials and Full FEM → Groundwater flow: the hydraulic properties of the layers and the boundary heads.
  3. Run the full 3D simulation, then compare on Results → Full FEM results and 3D / Full FEM → 3D analysis. Calculate still gives the 2D design result.
02 / How BoreTherm calculates it

From the 2D design to the coupled 3D model

1 Meshborehole, ground layers,13,230 nodes, 11,600 elements2 GroundwaterDarcy flow from the heads→ 9.9 × 10⁻⁸ m/s mean3 Heat transportconduction + advection,implicit time steps4 Borehole couplingfluid, pipes and groutlinked to the wall nodes5 Fluid temperaturehour by hour, 1 year→ TfMin −5.13 °C6 Sizing2D 75.95 m, full 3D75.13 m for TfMin ≥ 2 °C40 m fails the 2 °C limit in both models
The coupled heat and groundwater model of the aquifer example.
  1. MeshThe ground around the borehole is meshed in 3D, refined near the borehole.
  2. GroundwaterThe groundwater flow is solved first from the hydraulic heads and the permeability of the layers. The water balance closes to machine precision.
  3. Heat transportHeat is conducted through the ground and carried with the water.
  4. Borehole couplingThe borehole's fluid, pipes and grout exchange heat with the mesh at the borehole wall.
  5. Fluid temperatureThe coupled model gives −5.13 °C, close to the 2D result (−5.25 °C).
  6. SizingBoth models need about 76 m for the 2 °C limit.
03 / In BoreTherm

The example in BoreTherm

Full FEM → Physics & run: physics, mesh and time stepping.
Full FEM → Physics & run: physics, mesh and time stepping.
Results → Full FEM results: the coupled run against the 2D model.
Results → Full FEM results: the coupled run against the 2D model.
3D / Full FEM → 3D analysis: 2D and 3D temperatures compared.
3D / Full FEM → 3D analysis: 2D and 3D temperatures compared.
04 / Results

Calculated results

Calculated with BoreTherm for every variant of the example. Displayed values are rounded.

Model / projectTf min [°C]Tf max [°C]Limits met
2D analytic, aquifer case-5.247-2.690No
Full FEM coupled TH-5.131-2.747No
Full FEM transient pump stop0.0349.998Yes
Basic FEM-2.9098.605Yes
Groundwater / sizing metricValue
Mean Darcy speed [m/s]0.0000000990
Relative water-balance residual2.719688351451516e-15
Mesh nodes13230
Mesh elements11600
Required H, 2D [m]75.950
Required H, full 3D [m]75.134
3D and FEM analysis results plotted from BoreTherm output
Chart of the BoreTherm results in the tables of this section.

Temperatures by variant

VariantBoreholesLength H [m]Tf min [°C]Tf max [°C]Rb* [m K/W]Pump [W]Design limits
3D analysis, 100 m1100.000-2.9098.6050.142562.8within limits
2D, aquifer borehole140.000-5.247-2.6900.090050.6limits exceeded
full FEM, coupled140.000-5.131-2.7470.090050.6limits exceeded
3D sizing check, 100 m1100.000-2.9338.6010.142562.8within limits
transient boreholes150.0000.0349.9980.109234.5within limits
transient, pump stop150.0000.0369.9980.109234.5within limits
05 / Discussion

What the example shows

The 40 m borehole fails its 2 °C minimum in both models; sizing asks for 75.95 m in 2D and 75.13 m with the full 3D model. For this case the 2D method with groundwater is close to the coupled model.

The mesh is coarse for a short run time, and the hydraulic properties are assumptions. Check the solver, energy balance and mesh messages of every run before using its result.