The one idea: the ground is not one block
The analytic model of BoreTherm's design calculation builds the g-function, the dimensionless step response of the borehole field, from finite line sources (FLS: each borehole a line of finite length releasing heat into the ground), and adds the loads by superposition. It needs one thermal conductivity λ and one volumetric heat capacity C. Real ground is a stack of layers, and it may carry flowing groundwater. BoreTherm handles the layers by weighting them over the active length of the boreholes, the depth range [D, D + H] from the buried depth D (top of the borehole) to D plus the borehole length H (or by giving every layer its own response), and the groundwater by letting the heat source move with the water: the moving finite line source (MFLS).
λeff = Σ hi λi / H, Ceff = Σ hi Ci / HTu(z) = Ts + qgeo ∫0z dz′/λ(z′)vT = u (ρc)w / C, Pe = vT H / αF = evTx/2α ∫ s⁻² e−d²s² − c²/s² I(s) dshi: length of layer i inside [D, D + H]; Ts: ground surface temperature; qgeo: geothermal heat flux; u: Darcy velocity (specific discharge) of the groundwater; (ρc)w: volumetric heat capacity of the water; vT: velocity at which the heat moves; α = λ/C: thermal diffusivity; Pe: Péclet number, the ratio of heat carried by the flow to heat conducted over the borehole length; x, d: distance downstream and horizontal distance between source and receiver; s: integration variable from 1/√(4αt); I(s): the vertical part of the finite line source.
Everything after the g-function stays as for a homogeneous ground: the superposition (the load history as a sum of load steps, each answered by the g-function) uses λeff, the undisturbed ground temperature Tm averaged over the borehole and the effective borehole thermal resistance Rb* between the fluid and the borehole wall. Groundwater changes only the g-function; the grout is not flowed through.
The workflow
Two questions decide the ground model: how much is known about the layers, and does groundwater flow through them? Both are answered on the Ground page (Design › Ground). The design then runs as usual with Calculation › Calculate, which gives the mean fluid temperature Tf (the average of inlet and outlet), and Calculation › Size borehole length.
- Ground model: Homogeneous, Layered – effective properties, Layered – segmented. Layers are contiguous from the surface; the last layer extends to infinity.
- Undisturbed temperature: Mid-depth (Ts + qgeo (H/2)/λeff, the rule of the classic monthly design method, the default) or Active-length average (the mean of the geotherm over [D, D + H], used by the layered example project).
- Groundwater: a uniform aquifer (Darcy velocity u in m/yr, flow direction from +x counter-clockwise, water heat capacity), or a Darcy velocity per layer in the layer table. The page shows vT and Pe.
How the calculation works
- Reference values at the field's mean D and H: λeff, Ceff, αeff and Tm by the chosen temperature model. They define the units of the g-function (ts = H²/9α).
- Ground model. Effective: one layer with λeff, Ceff and the thickness-weighted mean Darcy velocity. Segmented: every layer with its own λ, C and vT.
- Segments. Segmented: the boreholes are split at every layer interface (and borehole section boundary), so each segment lies in one layer. A thin layer gets its own thin segment.
- Pair kernel. Two segments in one layer respond with that layer’s properties; in two layers with the mean λ and C of the pair. With flow, the kernel is the MFLS: the same integral plus a direction weight evTx/2α (x = how far the receiver lies downstream).
- g-function. The segment heat rates under a uniform borehole wall temperature (UBWT) give g. With flow, the pairs are grouped by distance and by position: downstream, upstream or across the flow.
- Superposition of the monthly loads as for a homogeneous ground.
Theory: layers
The layers of the layered example project and their weight in the effective properties (the length of each layer inside the active length of the boreholes):
| Layer | Depth [m] | λ [W/(m K)] | C [MJ/(m³ K)] | Inside [4, 154] m | Weight |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Clay / silt, water saturated | 0 – 8 | 1.7 | 2.4 | 4 | 3 % |
| Sand, water saturated | 8 – 25 | 2.4 | 2.5 | 17 | 11 % |
| Claystone / siltstone | 25 – 80 | 2.2 | 2.3 | 55 | 37 % |
| Limestone | 80 – 125 | 2.8 | 2.2 | 45 | 30 % |
| Granite | 125 – ∞ | 3.4 | 2.4 | 29 | 19 % |
Why the arithmetic mean. Around a borehole the heat flows horizontally, through all layers at the same time. The layers act as conductances in parallel, so their thickness-weighted mean is the right average. Layers above D and below D + H do not count, so λeff, Ceff and Tm change with the borehole length.
Effective or segmented? The effective model assumes every layer takes heat in proportion to its thickness. In reality a conductive layer takes more. The segmented model resolves that; for the example (contrast 1.7–3.4) it gives Tf,min −2.00 °C against −1.92 °C and a length of 140.9 m against 140.3 m. Use it for strong contrasts, thin poor layers or sections along the depth.
Theory: groundwater
The moving point source of Carslaw and Jaeger, integrated over two vertical segments, gives the MFLS kernel of section 1. Two things change against the conductive finite line source: a factor evTx/2α makes a receiver downstream feel the source more than one upstream, and the term e−c²/s² cuts off the long times, so the response becomes steady. The example's u = 1.0·10⁻⁷ m/s (3.2 m/a) gives vT = 6.0 m/a: the heat moves faster than the water's specific discharge u because the water carries heat into a ground that stores only C, not (ρc)w, per volume.
The price of the flow is a plume: the cooled ground ends up downstream. Without flow the −1 K isotherm reaches 35 m around the field; with flow it reaches 108 m downstream, over a width of 64 m. Check it against property lines and neighbouring boreholes on Results › Thermal plume.
How each result is derived
| Result | How BoreTherm derives it | Example project |
|---|---|---|
| Effective conductivity | λeff = Σ hi λi / H over [D, D + H] (parallel layers) | 4·1.7 + 17·2.4 + 55·2.2 + 45·2.8 + 29·3.4 over 150 m = 2.621 W/(m K) |
| Effective heat capacity | Ceff = Σ hi Ci / H; αeff = λeff / Ceff | 2.315 MJ/(m³ K); α = 1.13·10⁻⁶ m²/s |
| Undisturbed temperature | active-length average of Ts + qgeo ∫dz/λ over [D, D + H]; mid-depth: Ts + qgeo (H/2)/λeff | 11.07 °C (example); mid-depth 10.72 °C |
| Time scale | ts = H² / (9 αeff), the time axis of the g-function | 2.21·10⁹ s = 70 years |
| Heat-transport velocity | vT = u (ρc)w / C (u = Darcy velocity) | 1.0·10⁻⁷ × 4.18 / 2.2 = 1.90·10⁻⁷ m/s = 6.0 m/a |
| Péclet number | Pe = vT H / α (Ground page; Molina-Giraldo et al. 2011) | 1.90·10⁻⁷ × 150 / 1.18·10⁻⁶ = 24.1: advection dominates (axial effects negligible) |
| g-function, end of the grid | MFLS kernel; flow carries heat to or away from the field and g levels off | 14.06 with flow, 23.88 without |
| Lowest fluid temperature | superposition of the monthly loads with Tm, λeff, Rb* unchanged by the flow | −0.19 °C with flow, −2.41 °C without (H = 150 m) |
| Plume, −1 K | isotherm of the monthly base loads at the end of the period (plume command, analytic) | 108 m downstream, 64 m wide; no flow: 35 m around the field |
The example in numbers
| Ground | λeff | Tm | Tf,min at 150 m | Tf,max at 150 m | Sized length |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Homogeneous, no flow | 2.60 | 10.73 °C | −2.41 °C | 16.03 °C | 143.7 m |
| Layered – effective, active-length average (example) | 2.62 | 11.07 °C | −1.92 °C | 16.34 °C | 140.3 m |
| Layered – effective, mid-depth | 2.62 | 10.72 °C | −2.27 °C | 15.99 °C | 143.1 m |
| Layered – segmented, active-length average | 2.62 | 11.07 °C | −2.00 °C | 16.34 °C | 140.9 m |
| Homogeneous, groundwater 3.2 m/a (example) | 2.60 | 10.73 °C | −0.19 °C | 16.04 °C | 120.8 m |
Design limits −3.0 °C / 20.0 °C; the lowest temperature limits every length. Rows 1, 3 and 4 are the example projects with one input changed (no flow; mid-depth; segmented).
- Open the layered example project. Ground page: five layers, Layered – effective properties, Active-length average.
- Calculate: Tf,min −1.92 °C, Tf,max 16.34 °C. Size borehole length: 140.3 m.
- Open the groundwater example project. Ground page: groundwater 3.2 m/yr towards +x, Pe 24.1. Calculate: Tf,min −0.19 °C, Tf,max 16.04 °C.
- Results › Thermal plume: compare the extent downstream with the case without flow.
Limits to keep in mind
- Effective layers ignore vertical heat flow between layers and give every layer its thickness share of the heat. The segmented model uses the mean properties of two layers for a pair of segments; against a finite-difference reference it deviates 0.6–2.2 % at 50 years (strong contrast, thin poor layer).
- Mid-depth is the default because it reproduces the classic monthly design method. With known layers and buried depth the active-length average is the better estimate; the difference is typically a few tenths of a kelvin.
- Groundwater is uniform, horizontal and constant in time; no vertical flow, no thermal dispersion, the aquifer layers are horizontal and infinite. Tm and Rb* do not change with the flow.
- Darcy, not pore velocity. The input is the specific discharge u = K · i (hydraulic conductivity × gradient). A pore (seepage) velocity is u / n and would overstate the flow several times.
- Strong flow can expose near-field limits. The 3D analysis (a finite element model, FEM, of the ground with advection) is an independent check; the classic monthly method has no groundwater model, and the Equivalent g-function method falls back to the Similarities method with flow.
- The thermal plume uses the monthly base loads (no peaks) in an effective homogeneous ground.
Numbers calculated with BoreTherm. Theory: BoreTherm theory manual.