HomeFeaturesExamplesTutorialsHelpTheoryVerificationPricingContact
BoreTherm / TutorialsTutorial 04 / 19
Workflow and theory · Design basics

Inclined boreholes

How a field is inclined, how the geometry is checked, how inclined segments enter the g-function, and what tilt does to the design. The numbers come from two example projects, a fan and an arc of inclined boreholes: 21 boreholes of 150 m whose heads sit on a 1 × 2 m grid (7 per row, 3 rows), with illustrative office loads (heating 200 MWh, hot water 8 MWh and cooling 45 MWh a year, through a heat pump) over a design period of 25 years. The fan tilts the boreholes up to 20° at its edge; the arc tilts them from 10° to 30° along the rows.

01 / The one idea

The one idea: small head area, large volume of ground

A borefield is limited by the heat its boreholes take from each other. Vertical boreholes on a tight plot stay as close at 150 m depth as they are at the surface. Inclined boreholes start close together and spread out with depth, so each one draws on more ground of its own. The drilled length stays the same. BoreTherm designs the field from its g-function, the dimensionless step response of the ground to a constant heat rate in every borehole, built from finite line sources (FLS: each borehole a line of finite length releasing heat into the ground); from it follows the mean fluid temperature Tf (the average of inlet and outlet), month by month.

Side view of the middle row (7 boreholes)ground surface50 m100 m150 mheads within 6 mlower ends 93 m apartvertical (dashed): all within 6 mPlan: heads (dots) and lower ends (circles)20 mx east →, y north ↑
The fan example project, radial fan with 20° at the edge. Every borehole is a straight line of length H = 150 m along its axis. Left: true scale. Right: the plan, heads in the middle.
Axis of a boreholee = (sin θ cos φ,
     sin θ sin φ, cos θ)
p(u) = head + u e
Radial fantan θi = tan θ · ri / R
Arcθi = θ + Δ · (fi − ½)
fi = position 0…1 on the arc axis
Ground referenceHv = (1/N) Σ Hi cos θi

θ is the tilt from the vertical (at most 85°), φ the azimuth in the plan from +x (east) towards +y (north). H is the length along the axis; D stays the vertical depth of the head. A borehole of length H reaches only D + H cos θ deep. A negative tilt is the same borehole as |θ| with φ + 180°. The active length is the part of the borehole that exchanges heat, from the head at depth D to the lower end; rb is the borehole radius. Hv is the mean vertical extent of the field, the depth range the boreholes reach.

02 / The workflow

The workflow

Inclination is a property of the layout, set on Design › Field layout. A generated head pattern (line, rectangle, circle, …) takes one of five modes: Vertical, Same direction, Radial outwards, Radial fan or Arc. A custom field gets its tilts once from a mode, or borehole by borehole. The inclined field is then calculated with Calculation › Calculate and sized with Calculation › Size borehole length, as a vertical one.

Field layouthead pattern, spacing, rotationGenerated patternor custom field?patterncustomInclination group (pattern + mode)mode, tilt, spread, azimuth, arc axis,centre; every edit regenerates the fieldand is one undo stepCustom fieldApply inclination… sets tilt and azimuthonce (one undo step), or per boreholein the table or CSV (tilt_deg, azimuth_deg)Two axes closer thanthe sum of their radii?yesError: they intersectno new field; the lastvalid one stays shownnoCloser than the axiswarning distance (1 m)?yesWarningpair, distance, depth:check drilling tolerancenoLook at Plan and 3D, then Calculate and Size borehole lengthThe check runs on every field,vertical or inclined: on eachedit, and before everyg-function, simulation, sizingand optimizer candidate.Ctrl+Z takes back the lastedit, also a tilt that madethe field invalid.
Every field passes the same geometry check. An error stops the calculation; a warning does not. Ctrl+Z (Undo) takes back any edit, one step per change of a control.
Inclination groupmode and angles of agenerated patternPlan (2D) viewheads; the reportedpair is marked3D viewaxes in 3D; clearancecheck below 3 mBorehole tabletilt and azimuth ofeach boreholeAxis warning distancestored in the project,default 1 mStatus lineerror or warning withthe named pairCalculatewarnings in the results:close axes, B/HSize borehole lengthH along the axis; theratio Hv / H stays fixedDesign › Field layoutchecks and results
The pages and views involved. The 3D view’s clearance check (3 m by default, a setting of the view) is a visual aid; the project’s axis warning distance (1 m by default) is the one the calculation reports.
  • Modes. Same direction: one tilt, one azimuth (a compass direction that does not turn with the pattern). Radial outwards: one tilt, away from a centre (an azimuth offset makes a spiral). Radial fan: the tilt grows with the distance from the centre, θ at the farthest head. Arc: the tilt changes evenly along an axis, from θ − Δ/2 to θ + Δ/2.
  • Centre of the radial modes: the centre of the heads (default), the first head, or a point x, y. A head exactly at the centre stays vertical.
  • Rotation of the pattern turns the heads and the radial and arc directions with it; the azimuth of Same direction stays a compass direction.
  • Generation is refused (the last valid field stays, the status line says why) when a tilt exceeds 85°, two heads are closer than 2.2 rb, or two axes intersect. Converging modes (a negative fan, an inwards ring) usually end here.
03 / How the calculation works

How the calculation works

1 Geometry checkeach axis a segment;error / warning2 Segmentsn per borehole alongthe axis (8 here)3 Pair classessame relative geometry= same response4 Segment responseinclined FLS + image;closed form if parallel8 Simulation / sizingTf month by month;sizing keeps Hv / H fixed7 Ground referenceTm, λ, C over thevertical extent Hv6 g-functiong(t), withts = H̄² / (9α)5 Boundary conditionUBWT: one wall temp.,heat split solvedSteps 2–6 are the vertical g-function engine. Only step 4 differs, and step 7 uses the vertical extent.
From the field to the fluid temperature. A field whose tilts are all 0 takes the vertical code path and gives exactly the vertical results.
  1. Geometry check. Each borehole is the segment of its active length from (x, y, D) along e. For each pair of neighbours (found with a bucket grid, so thousands of boreholes take milliseconds) the smallest distance dij is compared with rb,i + rb,j (error: they intersect) and with the axis warning distance (warning). The message names the pair, the distance and the depth and plan position of the closest point. The simulation also warns when the spacing ratio B/H (smallest head spacing over the length) lies outside 0.02–0.5.
  2. Segments. Each borehole is cut into n segments along its axis (settings: g-function segments, 8 in the example). In layered ground a layer interface at vertical depth z lies at the measured depth D + (z − D)/cos θ; a segment belongs to the layer of its vertical mid-depth.
  3. Pair classes. The response between two boreholes depends only on their relative geometry, which does not change under a shift, a turn about the vertical or a mirror in a vertical plane. Pairs with the same key are calculated once (the Similarities method of the g-function). Inclined fields are not grouped by distance tolerance: the classes are exact to 10⁻⁶ m.
  4. Segment response. The inclined finite line source (section 4). Parallel segments (same tilt and azimuth) have a closed form, and so has the direct part of each borehole’s response to itself; all other pairs are integrated numerically.
  5. Boundary condition and g-function as for vertical fields (in the example UBWT, a uniform borehole wall temperature: all boreholes share one wall temperature and the split of the heat between them is solved); the time scale ts = H̄²/(9α) of the g-function uses the mean length H̄ along the axis (α: thermal diffusivity of the ground).
  6. Ground reference. Tm (the undisturbed ground temperature averaged over the boreholes), the thermal conductivity λ and the volumetric heat capacity C are those of the depth range the boreholes really reach, Hv, not H. A tilted field is a little colder on average: Tm rises from the ground surface temperature Ts with depth, driven by the geothermal heat flux qgeo.
04 / The theory

The theory: the inclined finite line source

For an emitting segment 1 (start p₁, axis e₁, length H₁) and a receiving segment 2 (p₂, e₂, H₂), the mean temperature change on 2 per unit heat rate per metre of 1 is the point source integrated over both segments, minus the same for the image of 1 above the surface (Lazzarotto 2016):

Response of 2 to 1h21(t) = F(t) / (2 H2)
F = ∫1/√(4αt)∞ [J(s; 1, 2) − J(s; 1′, 2)] / s ds
Receiver integral (analytic)J = ∫0H₁ e−s²ρ²(u) [erf(s(H2 − b)) + erf(s b)] du
Geometryb(u) = (p₁ + u e₁ − p₂) · e₂
ρ²(u) = |p₁ + u e₁ − p₂ − b e₂|²
Inclined finite line sourceground surface (T = Ts)image 1′ (sign −)ρ(u)p₁ + u e₁foot at b(u)emitter 1receiver 2Every point of 1 acts on 2 through ρ(u) and b(u).Why the closest pair is not at the heads89head spacing B = 1.00 md = B cos θ₉= 0.98 mθ₉ = 11.4°The top 1.2 m of boreholes 8 and 9, true scale.Borehole 9 leans towards 8; its axis passes thehead of 8 closer than the head spacing. The checkmeasures in 3D along the whole active length.
Left: the quantities of one segment pair. Right: the reason the example fan reports 0.98 m although its heads are 1 m apart.
  • b is linear and ρ² quadratic in u, so the integral over the receiver is analytic and one integral over the emitter remains. Where it is not a closed form, BoreTherm integrates adaptively (Gauss–Kronrod), with break points at the closest approach and at the ends of the receiver, to a relative tolerance of 10⁻¹⁰.
  • For vertical segments the formula is exactly the vertical FLS; inclined and vertical pairs therefore sit in one response model.
  • Self response. The wall temperature of a borehole is taken at rb from its own axis, for every segment of the same borehole. An open-source g-function library puts this receiver on the axis for two different segments of one tilted borehole; its tilted g-functions are 0.12–0.18 % higher at 10–25° for that reason.
g-function of the 21 boreholes, H = 150 m−10−8−6−4−2001020304050verticalarcfanln(t / ts)g1 month1 year25 yearsLowest fluid temperature, fan, H = 150 m0102030405060−8−6−4−2024example 20°: 1.63 °Cvertical: −7.81 °Climit −3 °Ctilt at the edge of the fan [°]Tf,min [°C]
Left: in the first weeks the boreholes do not see each other and the three fields are alike; after months the vertical field interacts strongly, the fan least. Right: the same 21 heads and 150 m, only the fan tilt changes (a study with the command-line program boretherm-cli, run when this document is built). Most of the gain comes from the first 10–20°.
The non-obvious part. A few degrees do most of the work. With heads 1 × 2 m apart the vertical field reaches Tf,min = −7.81 °C, far below −3 °C; tilting the fan by only 5° at the edge lifts it to −1.77 °C, and beyond 30° little is left to gain. Tilt helps most where the vertical field is crowded. It also has a price the g-function does not show: the ground reference moves up (Hv = 145.2 m, Tm 10.68 °C instead of 10.73 °C), and the lower ends leave the plot (51 m in the plan at 20°).
05 / How each result is derived

How each result is derived

QuantityHow BoreTherm derives itExample (fan)
Tilt of a fan boreholetan θi = tan θ · ri/R, about the centre of the heads; the centre head stays verticalborehole 9: r = 2.00 m, R = 3.61 m → θ9 = 11.4°
Azimuth of a fan boreholedirection from the centre to the head, from +x (east) towards +y (north)borehole 1 at (0, 0), centre (3, 2): −146.3°
Lower end of the active lengthhead + H · e; plan offset H sin θ, vertical depth D + H cos θborehole 1 (θ = 20°): 51.3 m out, 141.0 m deep
Closest approach of two axessmallest 3D distance of the two segments (head to lower end); error below rb,i + rb,j, warning below 1 mboreholes 8 and 9: B cos θ9 = 1.00 · cos 11.4° = 0.98 m
Spacing ratio warningsmallest head spacing / H outside 0.02–0.5 (the plan spacing, not the 3D one)1 / 150 = 0.007
Ground reference lengthHv = mean of Hi cos θi145.2 m (vertical: 150 m)
Undisturbed temperatureTm = Ts + qgeo · Hv/2 / λ (mid-depth form of the classic monthly method, D not counted)9 + 0.06 · 72.6 / 2.6 = 10.68 °C
Time scalets = H̄² / (9α), H̄ the mean length along the axis (not Hv)150² / (9 · 1.182·10⁻⁶) = 67 years
06 / The example in numbers

The example in numbers

Field (21 heads, 1 × 2 m)TiltsTm [°C]Tf,min at 150 mSized HClosest axes
Same heads, all vertical0°10.73−7.81 °C202 m—
Radial fan, 20° at the edge (example)0–20°10.681.63 °C107 m8–9: 0.98 m
Arc, centre 20°, spread 20° (example)10–30°10.62−1.59 °C137 m6–7: 0.89 m

Calculate at 150 m: the fan stays 4.6 K above the −3 °C limit, the arc 1.4 K. The arc tilts every borehole the same way, from 10° to 30°, so the field opens along the rows only; the fan opens in every direction. Size borehole length (the limit −3 °C binding) needs 202 m vertical, 137 m for the arc and 107 m for the fan: 47 % less drilling than the same heads vertical.

Required length H (along the axis), fan01020304050606010014018022020213910788tilt at the edge of the fan [°]H [m]Tm of the sized field01020304050609.510.010.511.011.5shorter and shallower:colder mean groundtilt at the edge of the fan [°]Tm [°C]
Left: the sized length falls with the tilt, steeply at first. Right: the shorter, more tilted field reaches less deep, so its mean ground temperature Tm falls; sizing keeps Hv/H̄ of the layout fixed while it changes H.
07 / Limits to keep in mind

Limits to keep in mind

  • Straight lines. Every borehole is a straight line from its head. Drilling deviation is not modelled; the close-axes warning says so: “Boreholes 8 and 9 come within 0.98 m of each other (axis to axis): check the drilling tolerances; the calculation treats the boreholes as lines.” Curved trajectories are not available.
  • Site plan: the site check tests the head (collar) of each borehole only. The lower ends of inclined boreholes can lie under a building or a neighbouring plot; check them in the 3D view with the site plan shown.
  • Not available for inclined boreholes: groundwater flow (the moving line source is vertical only), the approximate FLS, the adiabatic ground surface, and the hexahedral mesh of the finite element model, FEM (the tetrahedral mesh takes inclined boreholes). The Equivalent g-function method falls back to the Similarities method.
  • The optimizer (Calculation › Optimize) enumerates vertical layouts only; parametric studies (Tools › Parametric study) and Monte Carlo runs (Tools › Monte Carlo) can vary the tilt, spread and azimuth of a pattern. The classic monthly method has vertical boreholes only: an inclined project has no counterpart there.
  • An inclined g-function costs more: each pair is integrated on its own. A 10 × 10 field tilted outwards took about five times as long as the same field vertical (BoreTherm theory manual).
  • The spacing-ratio warning uses the head spacing (“The spacing-to-length ratio B/H = 0.007 is outside the usual design range 0.02-0.5.”). In an inclined field it says little about the real distance at depth; look at the clearance check and the result instead.

Numbers calculated with BoreTherm. The comparison runs (vertical heads, tilt sweep, sizing) are made with boretherm-cli simulate, study and size.