HomeFeaturesExamplesTutorialsHelpTheoryVerificationPricingContact
BoreTherm / TutorialsTutorial 05 / 19
Workflow and theory · Design basics

The heat pump

How building loads become ground loads, the two ways BoreTherm calculates the heat pump, the coupling loop, and how a machine is chosen and sized for. The example project is an office building with monthly loads of 200 MWh/year space heating, 8 MWh/year domestic hot water and 45 MWh/year active cooling (peaks 100 kW heating, 45 kW cooling) on a 4 × 4 field of 16 boreholes of 150 m, simulated over 25 years. It starts with fixed seasonal performance factors and holds three fictitious candidate machines (Alpha 110, Beta 60 × 2, Gamma 80); with Beta 60 × 2 as the project’s heat pump and the length sized for it, it becomes the solved example project.

01 / The one idea

The one idea: the borefield sees the heat pump, not the building

The Loads page holds building loads: the heat the building needs (space heating and domestic hot water, DHW) and the heat it must get rid of. The borefield never sees these numbers directly. It sees what the heat pump takes from the ground and puts back. The difference is the electricity of the compressor. How much electricity the heat pump needs is given by its COP (coefficient of performance: heat delivered / electricity, at one operating point) and, in cooling, by its EER (energy efficiency ratio: heat removed / electricity).

Heating and domestic hot waterElectricityW = Qheat / COPBorefieldthe groundHeat pumpCOPBuildingheating + DHWheat from the groundQheat · (1 − 1/COP)Qheatheat deliveredCoolingElectricityW = Qcool / EERBorefieldthe groundHeat pumpEER (active cooling)BuildingcoolingQcoolheat removedheat into the groundQcool · (1 + 1/EER)Passive (free) cooling: a heat exchanger, no compressor; Qcool goes into the ground unchanged.
Energy flows. In heating the electricity reduces what the ground must deliver; in active cooling the compressor heat is added to what the ground must absorb.
Heating and DHWQground = Qheat · (1 − 1/COP)
Active coolingQground = Qcool · (1 + 1/EER)
Passive coolingQground = Qcool

Over a season the COP becomes the seasonal performance factor SPF = heat delivered / electricity used (in BoreTherm including the electric backup and the source pump). With SPF 3.8, 1 − 1/3.8 = 74 % of the heat comes from the ground.

02 / The workflow

The workflow

There are two paths. Both end with a borefield that keeps the mean fluid temperature Tf (the mean of the inlet and outlet temperature of the fluid in the boreholes) inside the design limits; they differ in how well the heat pump is known. Both use the same two calculations: Calculation › Calculate, the design check at the current borehole length, and Calculation › Size borehole length, which finds the length that meets the limits.

Enter the borefield and the building loadsLoads page: heat, DHW, coolingIs the heat pump known,or being chosen now?noyesPath A — fixed seasonal performance factorsSetup: fixed SPF, e.g. 3.8 / 2.8 / 5.0Calculate (design check), Size borehole lengthOptional: Equipment selection → Calculateequipment requirements = the spec for the tenderPath B — temperature-dependent performanceSetup: heat pump model from a datasheet,or check candidates → Use in the projectCalculate, Size borehole length:coupled calculation, COP from TfCheck candidates again at the sized lengthmachine chosenlaterBoth paths size the same borefield. Path B adds the real COP of the machine, its capacity limit, the electric backup and its cooling EER.
Path A is the quick start and needs no machine. Path B uses a real machine. Path A turns into path B as soon as a machine is chosen.

In the program the heat pump has one home, Design › Heat pump, with three pages:

Loadsbuilding loads:heat, DHW, coolingHeat pump › Setuphow loads becomeground loads + modelCalculation menuCalculate (simulation),Size borehole length(sizing)Results summaryTf min / max,calculated SPFHeat pump › Equipment selectiondesign load basis, candidatedatasheets, requirementsHeat pump › Selection resultsrequirement sheet, check,coupled rerun per candidateOptionalthe borefield can be designedand sized without a machinecheckUse in the project: the candidate becomes the project’s heat pump modelmain pathchoosing a machine
Setup is the only place that decides how the heat pump enters the calculation. Equipment selection and Selection results are for choosing a machine; Use in the project is the bridge back to Setup.
  • Setup: How should heat-pump performance be calculated? — fixed seasonal efficiency or temperature-dependent performance — plus the SPFs, the cooling options and the heat pump model.
  • Equipment selection: the design load basis, the requirement sheet and the candidate machines from their datasheets. Optional.
  • Selection results: the requirement sheet, the check of every candidate and the coupled rerun of the design with each candidate.
03 / Two ways to calculate

Two ways to calculate

Fixed seasonal efficiencyTemperature-dependent performanceBuilding loads (Loads page)ground factor (SPF − 1)/SPF, fixedground loadsborefield → fluid temperature TfBuilding loads (Loads page)ground factor 1 − 1/COP, per monthground loadsborefield → Tf and field outletCOP from Tf, repeatSPF is an input. One pass; the machine never sees the field.SPF is a result. Up to 5 passes until it is stable.
Left: one pass, the SPF is an assumption. Right: the heat pump and the borefield are calculated together; the SPF is a result.

Fixed seasonal efficiency. Each load is multiplied by a constant ground factor, (SPF − 1)/SPF for heating and DHW and (SPF + 1)/SPF for active cooling. Quick and transparent, but the SPF is a guess and does not react when the field gets colder or warmer.

Temperature-dependent performance. The heat pump model (datasheet test points, a heating curve, capacity, minimum brine temperature, cooling EER; brine is the antifreeze fluid of the ground loop) gives the COP month by month from the actual fluid temperature. A colder field gives a lower COP, and the ground load changes with it. The SPFs on Setup are now only starting values.

04 / The coupling loop

The coupling loop

1 Startground factors from the SPFson Setup (starting values)2 Simulate the borefieldg-function, all years →monthly fluid temperature3 Operating point per monthsource: field outlet temperaturesink: heating-curve flow temp.4 Heat pump modelCOP(source, sink), capacity;shortfall → electric backup5 New ground factorsper month: share · (1 − 1/COP)SPF = heat / electricitychanged < 0.01?SPF and every factorno → next pass (at most 5)yes → Tf, calculated SPF, backup share in the Results summary
One pass = one complete borefield simulation. Size borehole length runs this loop at every trial length.
  1. Start. Pass 1 converts the loads with the SPFs on Setup.
  2. Simulate the borefield (with its g-function, the dimensionless temperature response of the field to a constant heat load; all years): monthly mean fluid temperature Tf.
  3. Operating point per month. Source = the brine leaving the field and entering the heat pump, Tout = Tf − Q/(2 ṁ cp) (Q > 0 = injection; during extraction the outlet is warmer than the mean; ṁ cp: mass flow × specific heat of the fluid). Sink = the flow temperature of the heating curve at that month’s outdoor temperature; domestic hot water at its own temperature (50 °C).
  4. Heat pump model. COP = η · COPCarnot, with COPCarnot = Tsink / (Tsink − Tsource + ΔTlift) in kelvin (ΔTlift: the temperature differences in the heat exchangers); the efficiency η is interpolated between the datasheet points. If the load exceeds the capacity, or the brine is below the machine’s minimum inlet temperature, an electric backup heater (COP 1) covers the rest. Backup heat takes nothing from the ground.
  5. New ground factors per month: share · (1 − 1/COP), where share is the part the heat pump covers. Active cooling: 1 + 1/EER. Passive cooling only while the fluid stays below the passive limit, otherwise active.
  6. Converged when the SPF and every monthly factor change by less than 0.01. At most 5 passes; if not converged, a warning says so.
05 / Why the COP matters twice

Why the COP matters twice

COP of Beta 60 at W35 (datasheet points)−505104564.24.96.1brine entering the heat pump [°C]colder field → lower COPShare of the heat from the ground: 1 − 1/COP23456750 %60 %70 %80 %90 %fixed SPF 3.80: 74 %Beta 4.80: 79 %COP (or SPF over the season)
Left: a colder field lowers the COP (W35: heating water flow at 35 °C; Beta 60 is one of the candidate machines of the example). Right: a higher COP takes a larger share of the heat from the ground.
The counter-intuitive part. A better heat pump uses less electricity, so more of the heat comes from the ground. In the example the fixed SPF 3.8 takes 74 % from the ground; Beta 60 reaches SPF 4.80 and takes 79 %. The net ground extraction rises from 143.1 to 160.5 MWh/a (+12 %)*, Tf,min (the lowest mean fluid temperature) falls from −2.41 to −3.84 °C, and the 150 m boreholes become too short. A field sized with a pessimistic SPF can be undersized for a good machine: size with the machine’s model, or with a realistic SPF.

* Annual sum of the monthly net ground loads, as Selection results reports it (months with both heating and cooling are netted).

The effect also works the other way round and limits itself: a colder field lowers the COP, which lowers the share from the ground. The coupling loop finds the balance.

06 / Choosing a machine

Choosing a machine: Equipment selection

1 Design load basisheat load, DHW surcharge,lock-out, operation2 Requirement sheetsimulates the design andderives the machine spec3 Candidatesdatasheet values of eachmachine you consider4 Check candidatesevery requirement line +a coupled rerun each8 Check againat the sized length(the field changed)7 RecalculateCalculate andSize borehole length,coupled calculation6 Use in the projectcandidate → heat pumpmodel on Setup5 Status per candidateMet / Tight / Not met;the worst line decidesNot met for every candidate? Add or change a candidate, or change the borefield, and check again.
From the design to a checked machine. Steps 1–5 change nothing in the project; step 6 does, as one undo step.

The requirement sheet is calculated from the design itself, with no candidate. It is the spec a brine/water heat pump must meet for this borefield:

RequirementHow BoreTherm derives itExample
Heating capacity at the design point(design heat load + DHW surcharge) × lock-out factor 24 / (24 − lock-out h); lock-out h: hours per day without power to the heat pump(100.0 + 2.7) × 1.00 = 102.7 kW
… at the catalogue point B0/W35the same, converted with the capacity curve of the heat pump model (B0/W35: brine 0 °C, heating water 35 °C)105.4 kW
Design pointoutdoor design temperature; brine = lowest field outlet temperature; flow = heating curve−12 °C / −1.3 °C / 35 °C, COP 4.31
Lowest brine inlet the machine must acceptTf,min − margin (2 K)−2.41 − 2 = −4.4 °C
Highest brine inletTf,max + margin (2 K)18.0 °C
Brine flow and pump headflow of the field; head = field + header pressure drop (+ the evaporator of each candidate)8.0 l/s, 190 kPa
Active cooling capacity and EERcooling peak; EER ≥ cooling SPF on Setup (temperature-dependent mode: the model’s EER)45 kW, EER ≥ 5.0

The check compares every line with each candidate’s datasheet and gives a status: Met with a margin of at least 10 % (capacities) or 1 K (temperatures), Tight with a smaller margin, Not met below the requirement. Then the design is simulated again with each candidate as the project’s heat pump (the coupled rerun): the candidate must also keep the fluid temperature inside the design limits. The worst line decides the overall status.

Use in the project copies the candidate’s datasheet into the project’s heat pump model (capacity × units, minimum brine temperature, modulation, cooling EER) and switches Setup to temperature-dependent performance. It does not change the borehole length and marks all results out of date. Run Calculate and Size borehole length afterwards, then check again.

07 / The example in numbers

The example in numbers

StateSPF heatingNet ground extraction [MWh/a]Tf,minLimit −3 °C
Fixed SPF 3.8 / 2.8 / 5.0, 150 m3.8 (input)143.1−2.41 °Cwithin −3 °C
Beta in the project, 150 m (Calculate)4.80 (calculated)160.5 (+12 %)−3.84 °Cbelow the limit
Beta in the project, sized: 160.0 m (Size borehole length)4.82 (calculated)161.1−3.00 °Cat the limit

Requirements at 150 m: 102.7 kW at the design point, brine down to −4.4 °C. Beta 60 × 2 meets every line of the sheet but not the design limits of the 150 m field. After sizing to 160.0 m it meets all requirements (EER only tight, because in the temperature-dependent mode the required EER is Beta’s own).

08 / Limits to keep in mind

Limits to keep in mind

  • With monthly loads the COP is evaluated per month; part-load lines (operating hours, starts) are estimates. Hourly loads give the real profile.
  • The SPF and the cooling SEER (seasonal EER: cold / electricity over the year) include the source pump electricity. With a large field pump the SEER can be far below the EER of the machine (the example: SEER 2.84 with EER 5.6).
  • With ground loads on the Loads page, or time-series loads, there is nothing to convert: the heat pump settings do not apply.
  • Equipment selection is a preliminary check against datasheet values you enter; BoreTherm has no product database. Check the manufacturer’s data, envelope, hydraulics and controls.

Numbers calculated with BoreTherm. The datasheets of the candidates are fictitious.