HomeFeaturesExamplesTutorialsHelpTheoryVerificationPricingContact
BoreTherm / TutorialsTutorial 11 / 19
Workflow and theory · Costs & comparison

Borefield costs

How BoreTherm turns a borehole design into a cost estimate, the simple and the detailed model, how the cost follows the length and the number of boreholes, and how sizing, the optimizer and the system comparison use it. The numbers are those of the example project: a small office or school building of about 3000 m² with monthly loads of 200 MWh/year heating, 8 MWh/year hot water and 45 MWh/year cooling, a 4 × 4 field of 16 boreholes of 150 m at 6 m spacing, simulated over 25 years.

01 / The one idea

The one idea: quantities from the design, prices from a list

BoreTherm does not ask for a lump-sum price of the borefield. It measures the design – metres drilled, boreholes, circuits, trench, grout, fluid – and multiplies each quantity by a unit price. The estimate is a list of lines quantity × unit price; every total follows from the lines. Change the length or the layout and the estimate follows at once, because nothing of the thermal model is recalculated.

the designquantitiesunit pricestotalsField layoutN boreholes, positionsBoreholeD, H, diameter, probeGround layersdrilling class eachFluid & flowvolume, glycol, circuitsTakeoffdrilled m by classdeep boreholes (> 100 m)probe m, grout m³circuits, manifolds, weldstrench m, pipe mfluid m³, kg, glycol kgSimple modelfixed, per borehole,per metre, per circuit,per metre of trenchDetailed modelprice list, groups A–F,one price per item,× regional × indexNetsum of the linesNet total+ contingencyGross+ VATline total = quantity × unit price; the net total is the value the optimizer ranks by and the comparison invests.
From the design to the totals. Both models price the same quantities; the detailed model has one line per item, the simple model five lines.
Drilled length of a boreholeLd = D / cos θ + H + foot
One line (f = regional × index factor)total = q · p · f
Net total: the ranking valuenet total = net · (1 + contingency)
Gross: for displaygross = net total · (1 + VAT)

D is the buried top part of the borehole above the active length H, θ the tilt from the vertical and foot the length drilled below H; q is a quantity, p its unit price. The probe is the pipe loop in the borehole, the grout the filling around it. The contingency is a reserve for the unforeseen, a percentage of the net.

The net total is the number that drives decisions: the optimizer ranks layouts by it, and the system comparison takes it as the investment of the borefield. VAT only gives the gross shown on the page and in the report (the comparison adds VAT itself when it works with gross prices).

02 / The workflow

The workflow

There are two cost models. Choose by what you know about the prices, not by the size of the project.

Design the borefieldground, borehole, field layout, fluid, loadsDo you have a price for each item?(tender results, your own .btcost list)noyesSimple model: five pricesfixed + per borehole + per metre+ per circuit + per metre of trenchmetre basis: drilled length or active Hold projects: their four optimizer pricesDetailed model: itemised price listgroups A–F, about 30 items, DIN 276drilling price per ground layerprobe price by type, glycol by fluidbuilt-in indicative list or your ownpricesknown laterNet total = net × (1 + contingency), without VATBoth models give the same kind of result: lines, group totals, net, contingency, net total, VAT, gross.
The simple model is a quick start and the model of every project from earlier versions. Switch to the detailed model as soon as you have item prices; the quantities do not change. DIN 276 is the German structure of building cost groups.

The estimate is computed on Economics › Borefield costs and used in four places:

Design pagesground, borehole,layout, fluidBorefield costsEconomics: model,prices, quantitiesSystem comparisonEconomics: borefield= one componentReportsection“Cost estimate”Size borehole lengthResults › Sizing: required H;cost at the sized lengthOptimize…Results › Layout optimization:each candidate pricedsized Hprices of every candidatenavigation treecalculations
The Costs page is live: it follows every change of the design. Sizing and the optimizer take the same prices.
  • Borefield costs: model switch, the five prices or the price list (Load…, Save as…, Library, Reset to built-in), the quantity options (foot length, grout excess, pipe routing, detour, header length, paved share, TRT (thermal response test) count, building entries, PE-Xa, drilling class per ground layer) and the summary with net, contingency, net total, VAT, gross and the indicators.
  • After Size borehole length (menu Calculation › Size borehole length) the page also shows the net total with the mean length scaled to the sized H, and the difference to the current design.
  • Optimize… (menu Calculation › Optimize) sizes every candidate layout and prices it at its own sized length; the objective Total cost ranks by net total.
  • Heating-system comparison prices the borefield again from the current design at every calculation (service life 50 years) and the report has a section Cost estimate.
03 / How the estimate is calculated

How the estimate is calculated

1 Each new boreholeLd = D/cos θ + H + footLp = Ld + 1 m; deep if Ld > 100grout, metres per class2 CircuitsC = parallel stringsmanifolds ⌈C / 16⌉welds 2 C + wb N + 2 links3 Trench and pipestrench = MST of heads+ manifold, × (1 + detour)pipes along the tree4 Fluidprobes + pipes + headers+ 2 l per manifold portmass ρV, glycol = w ρV8 Indicatorsper drilled metre,per active metre,per kW peak extraction7 Totalsnet = Σ linesnet total = net (1 + c)gross = net total (1 + VAT)6 Percentagesdesign and supervision:10 % of groups A–E(after the other lines)5 Price the linesquantity × price × ff = regional × indexdisabled item: 0takeoff (quantities from the design)pricing (simple model: five lines in step 5, no step 6)
Steps 1–4 are the takeoff (cost::takeoff), steps 5–8 the pricing (cost::price). The takeoff is the same for both models. Ld: drilled length, Lp: probe length, C: number of parallel circuits (strings of boreholes), wb: welds per borehole (by probe type), manifold: the header that joins the circuits, MST: minimum spanning tree, the shortest network that joins the heads.
One borehole (not to scale)ground surface100 m drilledD buriedH activefootLd drilledLp probe+1 m headThe field from above (16 heads, 6 m grid)manifold (□): the site’sconnection point, else thehead nearest the centroidtrench: shortest tree ofthe heads, × (1 + detour)one circuit: supply andreturn along the tree,+ 2 risers of 1 mPipes along the tree are pipe metres; the trench is priced once.
Left: the lengths of one borehole. The drilled length counts the buried part; the probe adds 1 m at the head. Right: the trench tree and one circuit of the example.

Existing boreholes (marked on the Field layout page) are connected but not drilled: they take no drilling, probe, grout or per-borehole cost, but they count for circuits, welds, connection pipes, trench and fluid. Tilted boreholes drill D / cos θ above the active part; their metres per drilling class follow the vertical overlap with each ground layer.

04 / How the cost follows the length and the number of boreholes

How the cost follows the length and the number of boreholes

Each line scales with one driver. Most of the money follows the drilled metres, but a good part follows the number of boreholes, the circuits and the layout:

Item kindExamples (detailed list)Scales with
Per field (lump sums)mobilisation, commissioning, geology and permit, documentation; mining-law notice once a borehole is deepfixed
Per new boreholerig set-up, probe installation, pressure test (simple: per borehole)number N
Per drilled metredrilling by class, depth surcharge, grout, probe (simple: per metre)N × Ld
Per circuitmanifold port, welds, connection pipe risers (simple: per circuit)strings C
Per metre of trench / pipetrench (unpaved, paved), connection pipes, header pairlayout, spacing
Per kg of fluidglycol concentrate (or premix)pipe volume
Percentagedesign and supervision: 10 % of A–E; contingency on the netall of the above
Net total of the field [k€]60100140180050100150200250300350400active length H per borehole [m]k€Net total per drilled metre [€/m]6010014018004080120160active length H per borehole [m]€/mLd = 100 msized Hdetailedsimpledetailedsimple
The example field (16 boreholes) priced at lengths from 60 to 200 m (cost --set borehole.H). Dashed: drilled length 100 m (H = 96 m) and the sized length 143.7 m.
Two non-obvious effects. First, the cost per metre falls with the length, because the per-field and per-borehole items spread over more metres. Second, the detailed list has a step at 100 m drilled length: a deeper borehole pays the depth surcharge (8 €/m) on its whole length, and one deep borehole triggers the German mining-law notice. In the example the net total rises by 17,374 € from H = 96 to 96.5 m, for 8 more metres. Two boreholes of 98 m drilled length can be cheaper than one of 196 m. The simple model has no such step.

The link to sizing. The thermal design decides the metres; the cost model only prices them. Size borehole length gives the required H of the current layout, and the Costs page shows what that length costs. The estimate never feeds back into the simulation.

The link to the optimizer. Optimize enumerates layouts on the plot (type, rows, spacing), sizes each one and prices it at its sized length with the project’s cost settings. Every candidate gets the default network (all boreholes parallel, or strings of the boreholes in series of Fluid & flow), and the manifold at the site’s connection point or the head nearest the centroid. Because the cost has steps (the 100 m class, manifold sizes, lump sums), the optimizer does not search with gradients: it compares candidates. Its candidates are vertical and unrotated.

05 / How each result is derived

How each result is derived

Detailed model with the built-in list “Germany 2026 (indicative)” (price date 2026-10), example field 16 × 150 m, single U, 25 % monopropylene glycol (MPG), homogeneous ground (class “mixed”).

ResultHow BoreTherm derives itExample
Drilled length LdΣnew (D / cos θ + H + foot)16 × (4 + 150 + 0) = 2,464 m
Drilling, by classdrilled metres in each ground layer × class price (homogeneous: one class)2,464 m × 55 €/m = 135,520 €
Deep boreholesLd > 100 m: surcharge on the whole length; one of them triggers the mining-law notice (DE)16 deep: 2,464 m × 8 €/m = 19,712 €; notice 1,000 €
Probe length LpΣ (Ld + 1 m head allowance), priced by probe type2,480 m × 5 €/m (single U) = 12,400 €
Grout volume1.2 × Σ (π/4 db² − nlegs π/4 do²) Ld40.76 m³ × 700 €/m³ = 28,532 €
Circuits, manifolds, weldsparallel strings C; ⌈C / 16⌉ manifolds; 2 C + wb N + 2 linksC = 16, 1 manifold, 64 welds = 3,200 €; manifold + ports 5,800 €
Trenchminimum spanning tree of the heads (+ manifold) × (1 + detour), unpaved / paved90 m × 70 €/m = 6,300 €
Connection pipesper circuit: supply to the first + return from the last borehole along the tree, + 2 risers of 1 m632 m × 10 €/m = 6,320 €
Fluid and glycolV = probes + pipes + headers + 2 l per port; m = ρ V; glycol = w m3.23 m³, 3,315 kg, 829 kg MPG × 6 €/kg = 4,973 €
Design and supervision10 % of the non-percentage lines of groups A–E10 % × 236,857 € = 23,686 €
Net → net total → grossΣ lines; × (1 + contingency); × (1 + VAT)263,843 € → 290,227 € → 345,371 €
Indicatorsnet total / drilled m; / active m; / kW peak ground extraction117.8 €/m, 120.9 €/m, 3,939 €/kW (73.7 kW)
Detailed estimate of the example: net total 290,227 € by groupA Site and preliminary works7,000 € (2 %)B Drilling155,232 € (53 %)C Probes, grouting, tests46,532 € (16 %)D Horizontal connection23,120 € (8 %)E Heat-carrier fluid4,973 € (2 %)F Design, permits, ancillary26,986 € (9 %)Contingency 10 %26,384 € (9 %)
Drilling (group B) is more than half of the net total. The percentages are of the net total.
06 / The example in numbers

The example in numbers

EstimateFieldDrilled [m]Net total€ / drilled m
Simple model, the project’s own prices16 × 150 m2,464131,200 €53.2
Detailed model, built-in list16 × 150 m2,464290,227 €117.8
Detailed, at the sized length (Size borehole length)16 × 143.7 m2,363280,347 €118.6
Best layout of the optimizer, simple pricesL-shape, 8 × 213.1 m, 10 m apart1,73792,320 €53.2
Best layout of the optimizer, detailed pricesL-shape, 8 × 213.1 m, 10 m apart1,737202,276 €116.5

The simple and the detailed model differ here because their prices differ, not their method. The example keeps the four prices of its optimization setup (fixed 5,000 €, 800 € per borehole, 45 € per metre of active length, 60 € per metre of trench, no contingency): an all-in price per metre that is far below the built-in detailed list (117.8 €/m drilled). Check which one stands for your market before you compare layouts or heating systems with it.

The sized length saves 9,881 € against the 150 m of the example. The optimizer finds a layout with fewer, deeper boreholes further apart: 8 × 213.1 m needs 1,737 drilled metres instead of 2,363. Both models rank the same layout first here; with other prices they need not.

07 / Limits to keep in mind

Limits to keep in mind

  • The built-in list “Germany 2026 (indicative)” holds indicative net prices from public sources, each with a range and a source; prices outside the range are marked amber. It is not a quote. Keep your own lists (.btcost) from your tender results; a price date older than two years gives a hint (set an index factor).
  • The estimate covers the borefield up to the header pipes and the building entry. The heat pump, the plant room and the building side are not in it; the system comparison adds them as separate components.
  • The quantity options (foot length, grout excess, detour) change the cost only; the thermal model does not see them.
  • The trench is the shortest tree connecting the heads; real routes are longer (use the detour) and may be paved (use the paved share).
  • Optimizer candidates get the default circuits; the explicit strings of the project and existing boreholes do not carry over to a new layout.
  • The simple model has no depth step, no geology and, by default, no price per circuit. Old projects keep their four prices with the active length, 0 % contingency and 0 % VAT, so their optimizer results stay as they were.

Numbers calculated with BoreTherm. Costs calculated with boretherm-cli cost, size and optimize.