HomeFeaturesExamplesTutorialsHelpTheoryVerificationPricingContact
BoreTherm / TutorialsTutorial 13 / 19
Workflow and theory · Advanced physics

Energy piles

How BoreTherm treats a foundation pile as a heat exchanger: the pile geometry, the ring model of the concrete, the boundary conditions, and the thermo-mechanical screening that goes to the pile designer. The numbers are those of the example project: a small office heated and cooled by a heat pump on 24 foundation piles of 20 m, Ø 600 mm, with 29 MWh/year heating and 12 MWh/year cooling as monthly loads, simulated over 25 years.

01 / The one idea

The one idea: a short, fat borehole that also carries the building

An energy pile is a cast-in-place concrete pile with the pipes tied to its reinforcement cage. Thermally it is a short, wide borehole whose filling is structural concrete. Two things set it apart: the concrete stores much more heat than borehole grout, and the pipes lie near the perimeter with a concrete core inside them. Mechanically the pile carries the building: a temperature change makes it shorten or lengthen, or, where it cannot move, builds up stress.

Cross-section of the pilecore: concreteinside the pipes, 193 mmpipe ring4 legs on the cagecover75 mm of concretegroundØ 600 mm, to scaleThe pile cooled by ΔT (heating mode)ΔLfree pileΔL = α ΔT H, σ = 0σfully restrainedΔL = 0, σ = E α ΔT (tension)the real pilelies between
Left: the example's pile (4 pipe legs of a double U on the cage). Right: the two mechanical bounds BoreTherm reports. A pile free to move changes its length and has no thermal stress; a fully restrained pile keeps its length and takes the full stress.
Pile temperatureTp = Tf − q Rb*/2
Change from the groundΔTp = Tp − Tm
Free pileε = αc ΔTp, ΔL = ε H
Fully restrained pileσ = Ec αc ΔTp

Tf is the mean fluid temperature (the mean of inlet and outlet), the temperature BoreTherm checks against the design limits; Rb* is the effective thermal resistance between the fluid and the pile wall. q is the ground load per metre (> 0 into the ground), so in heating the pile is a little warmer than the fluid. Tm is the undisturbed ground temperature, αc the thermal expansion coefficient and Ec the elastic modulus of the concrete, ε the strain and ΔL the length change of a pile of length H. A negative ΔTp (heating mode) shortens a free pile and puts a restrained pile in tension; a positive one (cooling) lengthens it or compresses it.

02 / The workflow

The workflow

The pile geometry comes from the structural design. The energy design checks what the piles can deliver and what temperature change they see. The ground side is the g-function, the dimensionless temperature response of the piles to a constant heat rate; its boundary condition at the pile wall is either a uniform heat flux (UHTR) or a uniform wall temperature (UBWT).

Foundation designpile diameter, length and positions are given by the structureBorehole cross-section › Energy pile ☑diameter = pile, shank spacing = pipe circle on the cage, concrete λ and C;U-loops in parallel or in series; switches the g-function to UHTRIs the ground under the pilescovered by a heated building?noyesGround surface: Isothermalopen ground, the defaultGround surface: Adiabaticinsulated slab: the colder boundDesign limits & simulationborehole model: Short-time capacity · cylindrical short-time correction onCalculation › Calculate → Results summaryTf within the limits · pile inlet range · Energy pile screeningΔTp, strain, length change, stress → the pile designerhandover
Ticking Energy pile sets the g-function boundary condition to UHTR (uniform heat flux) in the same undo step; a note offers to undo it. The 3D analysis (finite-element method, FEM) and the dynamic borehole model are not available for piles.
Boreholecross-sectionEnergy pile groupField layoutpile positions(grid, DXF)Loadsbuilding loadsand SPFDesign limits &simulationmodel, surfaceCalculate,Size boreholelengthResultssummary:screening
The pages involved; the runs are Calculation › Calculate and Calculation › Size borehole length. The Energy pile group on Borehole cross-section holds the switch, the concrete data of the screening (expansion αc, modulus Ec) and the pile inlet range.
  • Pile geometry. Borehole diameter = pile diameter. Shank spacing = diameter of the circle through the pipe centres (cage diameter minus bars and cover). Grout values = concrete values. The design library has piles of Ø 600 mm (double U, helix) and Ø 1200 mm (4 U-tubes).
  • U-loops. In parallel (manifold at the pile head) or in series (one pipe around the cage). In series every leg carries the whole flow: lower pipe resistance, much higher pressure drop.
  • Borehole model. Short-time capacity: the steady model plus the heat capacity of fluid, pipes and grout at short times. Only this model uses the ring model of the pile; the steady model treats the concrete as a resistance without storage, and the results warn about it.
  • Pile inlet range. Lowest and highest field inlet temperature Tin for the pile, default 0 °C and 40 °C. They give warnings, not sizing criteria.
03 / How the calculation works

How the calculation works

1 Pile resistancemultipole Rb, Rb*;loops parallel or series2 g-functionfinite line source, UHTR,surface isothermal/adiabatic3 Ring modelcore, pipe ring, cover:storage in the concrete4 Simulationmonthly base + peaks(or hourly): Tf, Tin8 Results summaryscreening + warnings;CLI JSON "energyPile"7 Pile inlet checkTin min ≥ 0 °C?Tin max ≤ 40 °C? (warn)6 Screeningmin/max ΔTp → strain,length change, stress5 Pile temperatureTp = Tf − q Rb*/2 on thesustained valuesSteps 1–3 run once per borehole design; 4–7 at every simulation (sizing: at every trial length).
Steps 1, 2 and 4 are the same as for a borehole. Step 3 replaces the equivalent pipe of the short-time model (all pipes on the axis, all filling outside them); steps 5 to 7 exist only for energy piles.
  1. Pile resistance. Rb and Rb* from the multipole method (an analytical solution for the pipes in the grout) with the concrete as grout. Loops in series get Rb* of the whole circuit.
  2. g-function. The finite line source at the pile radius with a uniform heat flux (UHTR), as in the pile literature, plus the cylindrical short-time correction. With the pile head at the surface the uniform wall temperature is not conservative.
  3. Ring model. A radial model of core, pipe ring and cover (next section). It changes only the short-time response; its long-time end is the steady model.
  4. Simulation. As for a borefield: monthly base and peak loads, or hourly. Tf and the inlet and outlet temperatures.
  5. Pile temperature from the sustained values: the monthly base in monthly mode (short peaks do not reach the pile as a whole), every hour in the hourly and time-series modes.
  6. Screening: the smallest and largest ΔTp of the whole period, then strain, length change and stress.
  7. Pile inlet check: the lowest and highest field inlet temperature (the coldest and warmest fluid at the concrete) against the pile range.
04 / The theory

The theory

The ring model: where the concrete stores heat

The equivalent single pipe of a borehole puts all pipes on the axis and all grout outside them. For a pile that is the wrong geometry: a large part of the concrete is the core inside the pipe ring. The ring model resolves it (16 core cells, 8 cover cells, 90 ground cells, second-order backward-difference (BDF2) time steps).

The capacity effect of a pile decays slowly, roughly as 1/t. BoreTherm therefore finds a blend time per pile: the time from which the effect stays below 1 % of the response, times four, between 100 h and one year (the BoreTherm theory manual gives about 184 days for a 0.6 m pile). Beyond one month the monthly base temperatures also get the correction.

Ring model of the pile, per metre (example values)fluidfluid + pipesRfr − Rzr0.0439 m·K/Wpipe ringC = 85 kJ/(m·K)Rzr0.0063junctionrR = 209 mmcover ln(rb/rR)/2πλ0.0320pile wallgroundto rfarcore ln(rR/rc)/2πλ0.0070core: C = 257 kJ/(m·K)Rfr + cover = Rb* = 0.0822 m·K/W: the steady end is exactly the multipole value. Rzr = (1 − x)(Rfr − Rp/n), x = 0.76.
Without capacities no heat enters the core, so the steady resistance from fluid to wall is Rfr + cover; Rfr is set to make it Rb*. rb: pile radius, rR: radius of the pipe ring, rc: core radius, rfar: outer edge of the ground model; Rzr places the ring concrete between the pipes and the junction; Rp: resistance of one pipe (film and wall), n: number of legs. The core (257 kJ/(m·K)) holds about as much heat per kelvin as the cover (272 kJ/(m·K)), and three times the pipe ring.

The pile temperature over the years

Pile temperature Tp, monthly baseJFMAMJJASOND468101214°C+2.12 K−3.98 KTm 9.3 °Cyear 1year 25Tf base, year 25undisturbed TmΔTp = Tp − Tm: thelargest change in eitherdirection over all years
Monthly base pile temperature in the first and the last year of the example, reconstructed from the result file as BoreTherm does (Tf base − q Rb*/2); its extremes equal the screening of the result. Tp is within 0.5 K of the base fluid temperature.
The point that is easy to miss. The screening takes the sustained temperature of the pile, not the fluid peaks. The coldest fluid (3.13 °C mean, 3.00 °C at the inlet) is a 6 h peak; the pile as a whole sees the monthly base. The largest cooling comes late (March of year 25), because the ground around a heating-dominated field keeps cooling for years; the largest heating comes early (August of year 1), before that drift. Run all years of the design life.

Model and boundary condition

Tf,min of the example over 25 years [°C]01234Steady resistanceno concrete storage2.33Short-time, not a pileequivalent pipe2.94Short-time, energy pilering model (the example)3.13Ring model, UBWTuniform wall temperature3.65Ring model, adiabaticinsulated slab above1.50limit: Tf,min ≥ 0 °C
The same project with one setting changed each (runs of the command-line program boretherm-cli). The concrete storage of the ring model raises Tf,min by 0.8 K against the steady model; an insulated slab lowers it by 1.6 K.
05 / How each result is derived

How each result is derived

The Results summary shows the screening under Energy pile screening (thermal load on the pile); boretherm-cli simulate --json writes it as energyPile (SI units). Example values:

ResultHow BoreTherm derives itExample
Pile resistance Rb*multipole method, as for a borehole (concrete = grout; the pipe circle = shank spacing)0.0822 m·K/W
Pile temperature TpTf − q Rb*/2: midway between fluid and pile wall; monthly mode: the monthly base Tf and base load q per metre; hourly modes: every hourJanuary, year 1: 6.73 − (−10.5 × 0.0822)/2 = 7.16 °C
Pile temperature change ΔTpsmallest and largest Tp − Tm over the whole period−3.98 K (March of year 25) / +2.12 K (August of year 1)
Free thermal strainε = αc ΔTp−40 / +21 µε (αc = 1.0·10⁻⁵ 1/K)
Free length changeε H, H = mean active length of the piles−0.80 / +0.42 mm (H = 20 m)
Fully restrained axial stressσ = Ec αc ΔTp; + compression (heating), − tension (cooling)−1.19 / +0.63 MPa (Ec = 30 GPa)
Pile inlet range (warning)lowest field inlet temperature ≥ the pile minimum; highest ≤ the pile maximumTin,min 3.00 °C ≥ 0 °C

αc and Ec are the defaults (the example does not change them); the column shows them as they follow from the result file (strain / ΔTp, stress / strain).

06 / The example in numbers

The example in numbers

Small office on 24 bored piles, 20 m deep, 4 m grid; double U 32 × 2.9 mm on the cage; concrete λ 1.8 W/(m·K), C 2.2 MJ/(m³·K); ground λ 2.0 W/(m·K), Tm 9.3 °C. Heating 29.2 MWh/a (seasonal performance factor SPF of the heat pump 3.8), cooling 11.7 MWh/a. Limits Tf 0 / 25 °C.

RunTf,min [°C]Tin,min [°C]ΔTp min / max [K]Restrained σ [MPa]
Example as delivered: short-time, ring model, UHTR, isothermal surface3.133.00−3.98 / +2.12−1.19 / +0.63
Steady resistance model2.332.20−3.97 / +2.12−1.19 / +0.64
Energy pile unticked (short-time, equivalent pipe)2.942.81––
Uniform wall temperature (UBWT)3.653.52−3.43 / +2.21−1.03 / +0.66
Adiabatic ground surface1.501.36−5.62 / +2.00−1.69 / +0.60
  • The screening hardly depends on the borehole model: it uses the monthly base. It does depend on the ground: the adiabatic surface gives −5.62 K instead of −3.98 K.
  • Free length change of a 20 m pile: −0.80 mm (heating) to +0.42 mm (cooling). Fully restrained: −1.19 MPa (tension) to +0.63 MPa (compression).
  • Without the energy pile box the short-time model falls back to the equivalent pipe: Tf,min 2.94 °C instead of 3.13 °C, and no screening.
07 / Limits to keep in mind

Limits to keep in mind

  • The screening gives the thermal input of the pile design, not the design. The real pile lies between the free and the fully restrained bound; its restraint comes from shaft friction, the toe and the structure. Axial force and mobilised friction need a load-transfer analysis by the pile designer.
  • One mean pile: Tp comes from the field's mean fluid temperature and is uniform along the pile. Centre piles of a group get colder than edge piles.
  • Monthly mode uses the monthly base: short peaks are not in ΔTp. Hourly loads give it hour by hour.
  • The ground surface is isothermal or adiabatic over the whole field. A building over part of the field, or an unheated cellar, lies between the two.
  • The ring model needs the pipes on a ring away from the axis. Pipes near the axis (rR − ro ≤ 0.1 rb, ro the pipe radius) and coaxial pipes use the equivalent pipe, with a warning.
  • Not for piles: the 3D analysis (FEM) and the dynamic borehole model. Loops in series do not work with borehole sections.
  • The pile inlet range gives warnings only; Size borehole length keeps the Tf limits and the optional inlet limit.

Numbers calculated with BoreTherm. Theory: BoreTherm theory manual.