HomeFeaturesExamplesTutorialsHelpTheoryVerificationPricingContact
BoreTherm / Example libraryExample 03 / 23
Worked feature example

Borehole construction

Compare single-, double-, triple-U and coaxial constructions at the office reference flow. A depth-section variant adds a deliberately insulated upper section.

16Boreholes
-2.41 °CMinimum mean fluid temperature
16.03 °CMaximum mean fluid temperature
5Variants compared
01 / Project

What the example does

The borehole heat exchanger of the office field is changed from a single U-tube to a double U, a triple U and a coaxial pipe, at the same total flow. A fifth variant insulates the upper part of the single U. The example shows how the construction sets the borehole thermal resistance and the pressure drop, and through them the fluid temperature and the pump power.

Inputs

InputValue
Field16 boreholes, 4 × 4 rectangle, spacing 6.0 × 6.0 m
Boreholeslength 150.0 m, top 4.0 m below the surface, diameter 140 mm
Constructionsingle U, PE pipe 32 × 2.9 mm, shank spacing 70 mm, grout 1.60 W/(m·K)
Groundthermal conductivity 2.60 W/(m·K), heat capacity 2.20 MJ/(m³·K), surface temperature 9.0 °C, geothermal heat flux 0.060 W/m²
Fluid and flow25 % monopropylene glycol, 0.50 l/s per borehole
Loadsmonthly: heating 200 MWh, hot water 8 MWh and cooling 45 MWh per year; peaks 100 kW heating and 45 kW cooling for 6 h
Heat pumpseasonal performance factors 3.8 heating, 2.8 hot water, 5.0 cooling
Design limitsmean fluid temperature between −3.0 °C and 20.0 °C
Period25 years
Variantssingle U (reference), double U, triple U, coaxial, single U with an insulated upper section

Run the example in BoreTherm

  1. Open Design → Borehole cross-section. Choose the construction, the pipe dimensions, the shank spacing and the grout.
  2. Read the panel Thermal resistance (live): Rb, Ra, Rb*, the Reynolds number and the heat transfer coefficient update with every change.
  3. For a depth section (for example insulation near the top), add sections under Borehole sections.
  4. Press Calculate; the pump power and the pressure drop are on Results → Results summary.
02 / How BoreTherm calculates it

From the cross-section to Rb*

The borehole thermal resistance links the fluid temperature to the borehole wall. BoreTherm calculates it from the cross-section with the multipole method and the flow regime in the pipes.

1 Fluid and flowproperties at 2 °C; flow perpipe → Re 4,958 (turbulent)2 ConvectionNu from the Gnielinskicorrelation → h 1,275 W/(m²·K)3 Pipe resistancewall conduction + convectionRp = 0.085 m·K/W4 Multipolepipes in the grout circle,order 3 → Rb, Ra5 Effective resistanceRb* adds the short circuitbetween down and up flow6 Pressure dropfriction over 2 × 150 m→ 190 kPa, pump 3.0 kWSingle U: Rb 0.115, Ra 0.440, Rb* 0.119 m·K/W
The resistance chain of the reference single U. The values are those of the Borehole cross-section page.
  1. Fluid and flow25 % propylene glycol at 2 °C and 0.5 l/s per borehole: the Reynolds number in the 26.2 mm pipe is 4,958, just turbulent.
  2. ConvectionThe Nusselt number (74) gives the heat transfer coefficient at the pipe wall.
  3. Pipe resistanceConduction through the PE wall plus the convection film.
  4. MultipoleThe multipole method solves the conduction in the grout between the pipes and the borehole wall: Rb between fluid and wall, Ra between the down and the up pipe.
  5. Effective resistanceAlong 150 m the fluid exchanges heat between the legs. Rb* (uniform heat flux) includes this short circuit; it is the value the design uses.
  6. Pressure dropThe friction factor of the pipe gives the pressure drop and, with the pump efficiency, the pump power.

More pipes is not always better. The double U halves the flow per pipe (Rb* 0.100 m·K/W); the triple U divides it by three, the flow becomes slower and the gain in Rb* is small (0.117). The coaxial pipe has a large annulus with laminar flow and the highest resistance (0.183).

03 / In BoreTherm

The example in BoreTherm

Design → Borehole cross-section: the single U with the live resistance panel.
Design → Borehole cross-section: the single U with the live resistance panel.
Borehole sections: an insulated upper section of the single U.
Borehole sections: an insulated upper section of the single U.
04 / Results

Calculated results

Calculated with BoreTherm for every variant of the example. Displayed values are rounded.

Borehole construction results plotted from BoreTherm output
Chart of the BoreTherm results in the tables of this section.

Temperatures by variant

VariantBoreholesLength H [m]Tf min [°C]Tf max [°C]Rb* [m K/W]Pump [W]Design limits
coaxial16150.000-4.37617.4650.1834598.0limits exceeded
double U16150.000-1.80915.5830.0997933.5within limits
single U (reference)16150.000-2.41316.0260.11943,033.2within limits
single U, insulated top section16150.000-4.12517.2810.17523,033.2limits exceeded
triple U16150.000-2.34915.9790.1173347.6within limits
05 / Discussion

What the example shows

The number of pipes, their wetted area and the flow velocity change together. The double U improves the minimum temperature by 0.6 K over the single U, the triple U by only 0.06 K. The pump power falls with more parallel pipes because each carries less flow. The coaxial pipe is the warmest in summer and coldest in winter: its annulus flow is laminar at this flow rate.

The insulated top section deliberately worsens the exchange near the surface; in this ground it costs 1.7 K. Section lengths and insulation values are illustrative.