HomeFeaturesExamplesTutorialsHelpTheoryVerificationPricingContact
BoreTherm / Example libraryExample 05 / 23
Worked feature example

Heat carrier fluids

Compare water, glycol, alcohol, salt brine, glycerol, custom constants and a temperature-dependent property table on the same field and nominal volumetric flow.

16Boreholes
-2.41 °CMinimum mean fluid temperature
16.03 °CMaximum mean fluid temperature
13Variants compared
01 / Project

What the example does

Thirteen heat carrier fluids are compared on the office field at the same volume flow: water, two glycols, two alcohols, salt brines, glycerol, a fluid with constant properties and a temperature-dependent property table. The example shows what the fluid changes: the convection, the borehole resistance, the pressure drop and the freezing margin.

Inputs

InputValue
Field16 boreholes, 4 × 4 rectangle, spacing 6.0 × 6.0 m
Boreholeslength 150.0 m, top 4.0 m below the surface, diameter 140 mm
Constructionsingle U, PE pipe 32 × 2.9 mm, shank spacing 70 mm, grout 1.60 W/(m·K)
Groundthermal conductivity 2.60 W/(m·K), heat capacity 2.20 MJ/(m³·K), surface temperature 9.0 °C, geothermal heat flux 0.060 W/m²
Fluid and flow25 % monopropylene glycol, 0.50 l/s per borehole
Loadsmonthly: heating 200 MWh, hot water 8 MWh and cooling 45 MWh per year; peaks 100 kW heating and 45 kW cooling for 6 h
Heat pumpseasonal performance factors 3.8 heating, 2.8 hot water, 5.0 cooling
Design limitsmean fluid temperature between −3.0 °C and 20.0 °C
Period25 years
Variantswater; monoethylene and monopropylene glycol; ethanol, methanol; sodium chloride, calcium chloride, potassium acetate, carbonate and formate; glycerol; constant properties; a property table

Run the example in BoreTherm

  1. Open Design → Fluid & flow. Choose the fluid and its concentration, or a table of properties against temperature.
  2. Read the properties at the fluid temperature, the freezing point, the Reynolds number and the pressure drop in the panel on the right.
  3. Press Calculate; compare Rb*, the pump power and the freezing check on Results → Results summary.
02 / How BoreTherm calculates it

What the fluid changes

1 Propertiesρ, cp, λ, μ at 2 °Cand the freezing point2 Flow regimeRe = ρ v d / μglycol 4,958; water 14,5003 ConvectionNu → h at the pipe wall→ pipe resistance Rp4 Rb*multipole with Rp; shortcircuit with ṁ cp5 Pressure dropfriction ∝ ρ v², viscosity→ pump power6 Freezing checklowest inlet temperatureagainst the freezing pointGlycol: Rb* 0.119 m·K/W, pump 3.0 kW, margin 6.2 K
The fluid properties enter the resistance, the hydraulics and the freezing check.
  1. PropertiesBoreTherm evaluates density, specific heat, conductivity and viscosity at the fluid temperature set on the Design limits & simulation page (2 °C here).
  2. Flow regimeThe viscous glycol is just turbulent; water at the same flow is clearly turbulent.
  3. ConvectionA higher Reynolds number gives a better heat transfer coefficient and a smaller pipe resistance.
  4. Rb*The pipe resistance enters the multipole solution; the heat capacity flow sets the short circuit between the legs.
  5. Pressure dropViscosity and density set the friction losses and the pump power.
  6. Freezing checkThe lowest inlet temperature (−3.57 °C in year 25) stays 6.2 K above the freezing point of 25 % propylene glycol (−9.8 °C).
03 / In BoreTherm

The example in BoreTherm

Design → Fluid & flow: properties, flow and freezing point.
Design → Fluid & flow: properties, flow and freezing point.
The fluid library: concentrations and freezing points.
The fluid library: concentrations and freezing points.
A temperature-dependent property table.
A temperature-dependent property table.
04 / Results

Calculated results

Calculated with BoreTherm for every variant of the example. Displayed values are rounded.

Heat carrier fluids results plotted from BoreTherm output
Chart of the BoreTherm results in the tables of this section.

Temperatures by variant

VariantBoreholesLength H [m]Tf min [°C]Tf max [°C]Rb* [m K/W]Pump [W]Design limits
calcium chloride16150.000-2.37215.9960.11812,822.4within limits
constant properties16150.000-2.39516.0130.11882,853.2within limits
ethanol16150.000-2.42316.0330.11972,988.6within limits
monopropylene glycol 25 % (reference)16150.000-2.41316.0260.11943,033.2within limits
glycerol16150.000-2.49216.0840.12203,559.7within limits
methanol16150.000-2.37215.9960.11812,523.6within limits
monoethylene glycol16150.000-2.38116.0030.11842,747.8within limits
potassium acetate16150.000-2.37415.9970.11812,852.7within limits
potassium carbonate16150.000-2.36315.9900.11783,201.0within limits
potassium formate16150.000-2.36315.9890.11782,789.6within limits
property table16150.000-2.41716.0290.11963,027.5within limits
sodium chloride16150.000-2.34615.9770.11722,707.5within limits
water16150.000-2.31515.9540.11622,216.5within limits
05 / Discussion

What the example shows

The minimum temperatures differ by less than 0.2 K between the fluids: at this flow the resistance is dominated by the grout. The pump power differs much more, from 2.2 kW with water to 3.6 kW with glycerol. Compare Reynolds number, pressure drop, pump power and freezing margin together.

Water passes the design limits here, but its inlet temperature falls below 0 °C: BoreTherm warns about freezing even when the mean temperature limits are met. The property table is a synthetic example, not a supplier data sheet.