HomeFeaturesExamplesTutorialsHelpTheoryVerificationPricingContact
BoreTherm / Example libraryExample 19 / 23
Worked feature example

Heating-system comparison

Compare ground- and air-source heat pumps, fuel boilers, district heat and a hybrid for the same office heating, domestic hot water and cooling service.

16Boreholes
-2.41 °CMinimum mean fluid temperature
16.03 °CMaximum mean fluid temperature
1Variants compared
01 / Project

What the example does

Is the ground-source heat pump the best choice for the office? BoreTherm compares it with an air-source heat pump, gas and oil condensing boilers, a pellet boiler, district heating and a hybrid of air-source heat pump and gas boiler, for the same heating, hot water and cooling.

Inputs

InputValue
Field16 boreholes, 4 × 4 rectangle, spacing 6.0 × 6.0 m
Boreholeslength 150.0 m, top 4.0 m below the surface, diameter 140 mm
Constructionsingle U, PE pipe 32 × 2.9 mm, shank spacing 70 mm, grout 1.60 W/(m·K)
Groundthermal conductivity 2.60 W/(m·K), heat capacity 2.20 MJ/(m³·K), surface temperature 9.0 °C, geothermal heat flux 0.060 W/m²
Fluid and flow25 % monopropylene glycol, 0.50 l/s per borehole
Loadsmonthly: heating 200 MWh, hot water 8 MWh and cooling 45 MWh per year; peaks 100 kW heating and 45 kW cooling for 6 h
Heat pumpseasonal performance factors 3.8 heating, 2.8 hot water, 5.0 cooling
Design limitsmean fluid temperature between −3.0 °C and 20.0 °C
Period25 years
ComparisonGerman data set 2026-10: prices, efficiencies, service lives and emission factors; 20 years; real prices, gross

Run the example in BoreTherm

  1. Open Economics → Heating-system comparison and switch the comparison on. Choose the systems, the period, the interest and the data scenario.
  2. Press Calculate: the comparison is calculated with the design.
  3. Results → System comparison shows the annual cost, the cumulative cost, CO₂, primary energy and the assumptions with their sources.
02 / How BoreTherm calculates it

How the systems are compared

1 Same serviceheating, hot water andcooling of the building2 Energy per systemground: simulated SPFothers: efficiencies3 Investmentequipment, installation,borefield cost4 Annuityinvestment over the servicelife + energy + maintenance5 Cost of heatannuity / heat delivered→ EUR/kWh6 Emissionsenergy × emission factorsstatutory and realGround source 0.154 EUR/kWh; air source 0.137 EUR/kWh
All systems deliver the same service; only the technology changes.
  1. Same serviceEvery system covers the same useful heat, hot water and cooling.
  2. Energy per systemThe ground-source heat pump uses the seasonal performance factor from the borefield simulation (4.66 including auxiliaries).
  3. InvestmentThe ground-source system includes the borefield estimate.
  4. AnnuityInvestment converted into a yearly cost with the interest and service life, plus energy and maintenance.
  5. Cost of heatThe annuity divided by the heat delivered.
  6. EmissionsTwo conventions: the statutory factors and the real emissions.
03 / In BoreTherm

The example in BoreTherm

Economics → Heating-system comparison: systems and assumptions.
Economics → Heating-system comparison: systems and assumptions.
Results → System comparison: annual cost, cost of heat and CO₂.
Results → System comparison: annual cost, cost of heat and CO₂.
The cumulative cost of every system over the period.
The cumulative cost of every system over the period.
04 / Results

Calculated results

Calculated with BoreTherm for every variant of the example. Displayed values are rounded.

Application assumption dataset: DE 2026-10; data date 2026-10-18.

SystemAnnual annuity [EUR/a]LCOH heat [EUR/kWh]SPF totalStatutory CO₂ [t/a]Real CO₂ [t/a]
BHE heat pump34,154.460.15444.66329.06517.854
Air/water heat pump31,733.500.13744.44532.50419.967
Gas condensing boiler40,299.030.16570.00059.28443.780
Oil condensing boiler45,291.840.18970.00076.64563.984
Pellet boiler35,501.600.14260.00012.0184.543
District heating41,036.400.16920.00045.46036.294
Hybrid air/water heat pump and gas boiler40,269.080.16550.00037.01922.924
Heating-system comparison results plotted from BoreTherm output
Chart of the BoreTherm results in the tables of this section.

Temperatures by variant

VariantBoreholesLength H [m]Tf min [°C]Tf max [°C]Rb* [m K/W]Pump [W]Design limits
office reference16150.000-2.41316.0260.11943,033.2within limits
05 / Discussion

What the example shows

With these 2026 assumptions the air-source heat pump has the lowest annual cost (31,734 EUR/a); the ground-source heat pump follows (34,154 EUR/a) with the best efficiency and lower CO₂ than the air-source heat pump. The result depends on the stated tariffs, efficiencies, service lives and emission factors; the low and high scenarios of the data set show how much.

The data set and its date are part of every result. Grants and compliance with national rules need verified data.