HomeFeaturesExamplesTutorialsHelpTheoryVerificationPricingContact
BoreTherm / Published referencesReference R5 / R9
Published reference · Heat pump selection

Bonin, solution 18.2: selecting a brine/water heat pump

A house on four double-U borehole heat exchangers. Four catalogue heat pumps are checked for capacity, minimum brine flow, buffer volume and brine pump head; a utility lock-out variant follows.

13.53 kWRequired heating capacity
SW 15.000Book’s choice; BoreTherm: capacity met
66.6 kPaBoreTherm brine pump head
0.81 barBook pump head, corrected
01 / Project

Source, inputs and purpose

Source. Bonin, J. (2015). Heat Pump Planning Handbook. Routledge. Task 15.2 (p. 252) and its solution 18.2, pp. 276–283; lock-out §5.2.5 (p. 97); candidates from Table 5.12 (p. 123) and Tables 18.3 / 18.4 (pp. 277, 280).

Inputs and reference results are taken from the cited publication; BoreTherm results were calculated with BoreTherm on the project rebuilt from those inputs; differences are explained below.

What the example checks

The example is about choosing the heat pump, not about the ground: which unit covers the heating and hot water load, whether the field’s brine flow reaches the unit’s minimum, whether the buffer is large enough, and what pump head the brine circuit needs. A variant adds a daily utility lock-out.

Inputs

Values marked Assumption are not given in the book and were chosen for the BoreTherm project; the others are the book’s, with the section or page.

InputValueSource
Heating load45 W/m² × 274 m² = 12.33 kW; domestic hot water 4 × 0.3 kW = 1.2 kW; monovalent18.2
Heating systemunderfloor heating, 35 °C flow, design outdoor temperature −12 °C18.2
Borehole heat exchangersfour double U of 85–90 m (the project uses 4 × 88 m), specific extraction 35 W/m18.2
Brine flow3.9 m³/h, the minimum flow of the SW 15.00018.2
Hydraulicsheader and connection pipes 0.15 bar + fittings 0.07 bar (22 kPa); free-cooling heat exchanger 0.20 barp. 279
Buffer300 l18.2
Candidates, B0/W35GeoMax SW 10.300 / 12.400 / 15.000 / 16.800: 10.3 / 12.4 / 15.0 / 16.8 kW, COP 4.2 / 4.2 / 4.4 / 4.4Table 5.12
Candidates, minimum brine flow2.6 / 3.2 / 3.9 / 4.4 m³/hTables 18.3, 18.4
Candidates, evaporator pressure drop0.20 / 0.18 / 0.17 / 0.21 bar at those flowsTables 18.3, 18.4
Ground1.8 W/(m·K), 2.2 MJ/(m³·K), 10 °CAssumption
Field and boreholes4 × 88 m in a row at 6 m, 150 mm, PE 32 × 2.9 mm, grout 2.0 W/(m·K), 25 % monoethylene glycolAssumption
Loads over the yearheating 20.3 MWh/a with the monthly shape of a German single-family house, hot water 4.0 MWh/a, free cooling 2 MWh/aAssumption
Efficiency and limitsfixed seasonal performance factor 4.4; minimum mean fluid temperature −3 °CAssumption
Lock-out variant231 m² → 10.4 kW, hot water 1.4 kW, 4 h lock-out per day (factor 1.2); brine flow 4.4 m³/h§5.2.5, p. 97; flow: Assumption

Run the example in BoreTherm

  1. Open the brine/water heat pump reference project (or its lock-out variant) from the examples folder (File → Open).
  2. Press Calculate, open Design → Heat pump → Selection results and click Check candidates.
02 / How BoreTherm calculates it

How the heat pump is checked

1 Requirement12.33 kW heating + 1.2 kWhot water → 13.53 kW2 Capacityeach candidate at thedesign source temperature3 Brine flowfield flow 3.9 m³/h againstthe unit's minimum4 Buffervolume rule againstthe 300 l buffer5 Pump headfield 7.6 + header 22.0 +HX 20.0 + evaporator 17.06 Coupled rerunfield simulated with eachcandidate's efficiencySW 15.000: capacity met, head 66.6 kPa
The requirement sheet and the checks of every candidate.
  1. RequirementHeating load plus hot water, monovalent.
  2. CapacityEach unit's capacity at the design point against the requirement.
  3. Brine flowThe SW 16.800 needs 4.4 m³/h; the field delivers 3.9 m³/h.
  4. BufferThe minimum buffer volume of each unit.
  5. Pump headThe brine pump must overcome the field, header, heat exchanger and evaporator.
  6. Coupled rerunThe field is simulated again with each unit's efficiency.
03 / In BoreTherm

The example in BoreTherm

Design → Heat pump → Equipment selection: the four catalogue units.
Design → Heat pump → Equipment selection: the four catalogue units.
Design → Heat pump → Selection results: requirement sheet and candidate statuses.
Design → Heat pump → Selection results: requirement sheet and candidate statuses.
04 / Results

Calculated results

Displayed values are rounded. Differences are BoreTherm relative to the book unless stated otherwise.

QuantityBookBoreThermDifference
Required heating capacity13.5 kW13.53 kWequal
SW 10.300 / SW 12.400, capacity–−23.9 % / −8.4 %, not met–
SW 15.000, capacitychosen+10.9 %, met; overall Tightsame choice
SW 16.800–+24.2 % capacity; overall not met: field flow 11.4 % below its 4.4 m³/h minimum–
Buffer for the SW 15.000300 lat least 0.215 m³ needed: metconsistent
Brine pump head for the SW 15.0000.71 bar printed; 0.81 bar with the loop loss corrected66.6 kPa = field 7.6 + header 22.0 + heat exchanger 20.0 + evaporator 17.0−18 % against 0.81 bar
Total borehole length343 m (rule of thumb with 35 W/m)264 m (4 × 66.1 m) on the assumed ground−23 %

Lock-out variant

Section 5.2.5: a smaller house with 4 hours of utility lock-out per day.

QuantityBookBoreThermDifference
Required heating capacity(10.4 + 1.4) × 1.2 = 14.2 kW14.16 kWequal (printed rounded)
SW 15.000chosen as the next size+5.9 %, Tightsame choice
SW 16.800–+18.6 %, met; overall Tight–
Brine pump head for the SW 15.000 at 4.4 m³/h–72.2 kPa–
05 / Discussion

Why the results differ

Capacity and selection

The capacity statuses follow from the book’s load and catalogue numbers, so BoreTherm reaches the same choice. The SW 16.800 has enough capacity, but its minimum brine flow is 4.4 m³/h while this field is designed for the 3.9 m³/h of the SW 15.000, so BoreTherm rates it not met. In the lock-out variant the field runs at 4.4 m³/h (an assumption) so that both larger units are compared on capacity alone.

The chosen SW 15.000 is rated Tight overall, from checks the book does not make: the design source temperature lies outside the datasheet’s rated range, the estimated part-load profile favours a modulating unit, and its efficiency at the 1.1 °C design source (COP 4.52) draws 0.8 % more heat from the ground than the seasonal factor the field was simulated with.

Pump head

The whole difference lies in the borehole loop. The flow in the loops is laminar (Reynolds number about 1,850 with 25 % glycol near 0 °C), and BoreTherm’s 7.6 kPa matches the laminar hand formula (7.7 kPa). The book uses a tabulated planning value of 1.2 m per 100 m over 180 m, 22 kPa. With the book’s loop loss, BoreTherm’s sum is 0.81 bar exactly. The book calculates the loop loss as 0.22 bar on p. 279 but adds 0.12 bar in its total, which is why it prints 0.71 bar.

Length

The book sizes the boreholes with a specific extraction rate (35 W/m for 1,800 hours a year), a rule of thumb. BoreTherm simulates the field on an assumed ground, so the −23 % says only that the rule is conservative for that ground. At the book’s 4 × 88 m, BoreTherm’s minimum mean fluid temperature is −0.05 °C.

BoreTherm features exercised