HomeFeaturesExamplesTutorialsHelpTheoryVerificationPricingContact
Theory manual

20. Energy piles

An energy pile is a cast-in-place concrete foundation pile with heat exchanger pipes tied to its reinforcement cage. Thermally it is a short (10–40 m), wide (0.3–1.5 m) borehole whose filling is structural concrete. Two things set it apart from a borehole (Loveridge & Powrie 2013, 2014): the concrete stores much more heat than borehole grout, so the pile stays transient for days to months rather than hours; and the pipes lie near the perimeter, with a concrete core inside them and only the cover outside. Mechanically the pile carries the building: a temperature change makes it shorten or lengthen, or builds up stress where it cannot move.

A design is marked as an energy pile in the Energy pile group of the Borehole cross-section page. The borehole diameter is then the pile diameter, the grout values are those of the concrete, and the shank spacing is the diameter of the circle through the pipe centres (the cage diameter minus the bars and the cover). The steady model, the multipole pile resistance and the g-function keep their form; the short-time model uses the ring model of this chapter, the g-function boundary condition becomes a uniform heat flux, and the results add a thermo-mechanical screening and a check of the inlet temperatures at the pile.

20.1 Pipes on the cage

Rb=Rpl1+ln(rb/rc)2πλc+ln(2sn/(πdo))+ln((1−e−4πz/sn)/2)2πλcl1
(20.1)

with λc the concrete conductivity. Against an axisymmetric ring-coil model (the idealisation of Cui et al. 2011) this Rb agrees within 0.6–0.8 %. Spiral coils are not available with borehole sections or the dynamic model.

20.2 The ring model of the concrete

The equivalent single pipe of the short-time model of boreholes puts all pipes on the axis and all filling outside them. For a pile that is the wrong geometry: a large part of the concrete is the core inside the pipe ring. The ring model resolves it. With rR=s/2 the radius of the pipe centres, ro the outer pipe radius and n the number of legs, the cross-section is

The network is: fluid node (fluid and pipe walls of all legs) – resistance Rfr−Rzr – pipe-zone node (the ring concrete) – resistance Rzr – ring junction. The junction connects inwards through ln(rR/rc)/(2πλc) to the core and outwards through ln(rb/rR)/(2πλv) to the pile wall. Without capacities no heat enters the core, so the steady fluid-to-wall resistance is

Rb*=Rfr+ln(rb/rR)2πλv
(20.2)

and Rfr is set to make it the multipole Rb*: the long-time end of the ring model is the steady model. Rfr must at least hold the film and wall resistances of the legs in parallel, Rp/n; when a small Rb* does not allow that, the cover conductivity λv is raised until Rfr=min(Rp/n, 0.95Rb*), otherwise λv=λc.

The concrete next to the pipes takes up heat before heat crosses the full concrete path to the ring. As for the grout node of the borehole network (Bauer et al. 2011), each leg owns its share of the ring, A=[π((rR+ro)2−rc2)−nπro2]/n, a circle of radius req, and the pipe-zone node sits at the radius rx that halves this area:

req=ro2+A/π,rx=ro2+req22,x=ln(rx/ro)ln(req/ro),Rzr=(1−x)(Rfr−Rpn)
(20.3)

Typical piles give x≈0.75; nothing is fitted. The finite volumes are those of the borehole radial model: 16 equal core cells, 8 cover cells and 90 logarithmically spaced ground cells, with second-order backward differences in time. The fluid and pipe-zone nodes are eliminated into the junction row, so a time step is one tridiagonal solve. The capacity correction is the difference of two runs with and without the capacities of fluid, pipes and concrete:

δg(t)=2πλ[Tf(t; capacities)−Tf(t; no capacities)]w(t),gc=g+2πλRb*+δg
(20.4)

In the example pile below, the core holds about as much heat per kelvin as the cover (257 against 272 kJ/(m K)) and three times as much as the pipe ring.

20.2.1 Blend time per pile

The capacity effect of a pile decays slowly, roughly as 1/t: for a 1.2 m pile it is still 4 % of the response after 30 days and 1.7 % after 90 days. The fixed 100 h of boreholes would cut it off. The ring model is therefore run to one year to find the time tε from which the un-blended effect stays below 1 % of the response without capacities, and

tblend=min(max(4tε, 100 h), 1 year)
(20.5)

so that the blend starts where the effect is already at most 1 %. Typical values: 39 days for a 0.3 m pile, 184 days for 0.6 m, one year for 0.9 m and above. Beyond one month the monthly base temperatures also get the correction, and long hourly convolutions run through the fast Fourier transform. Pipes near the axis (rR−ro≤0.1rb, a single U-tube on a centre bar) and coaxial pipes use the equivalent pipe, which is that geometry, and the results say so.

20.3 The ground side: g-function and the building above

The g-function of a pile group is the finite line source at the pile radius, with three points that matter for piles:

The building above the piles. The finite line source mirrors every segment at the ground surface. The default isothermal surface subtracts the image (a heat sink at the surface temperature). An insulated slab over the field is better described by an adiabatic surface, which adds the image instead; the real terms are unchanged, so

gadiabatic+gisothermal2=gfull space
(20.6)

With no heat exchange through the surface the long-time g-function keeps rising. For a 3 × 3 group of 20 m piles 3 m apart, g after 10 years is 13.1 instead of 8.1, and over 20 years of heating only the minimum fluid temperature is 4.6 K lower. The two conditions bound a real building: a heated basement over an insulated slab is close to adiabatic, an unheated or ventilated cellar lies in between. For a building heated all year, set the surface temperature to the long-term temperature under the slab. A building over only part of the field has no closed form in the finite line source; use the bounds.

20.4 Pile-specific limits and the thermo-mechanical screening

Inlet temperature range. The coldest fluid at the concrete is the field inlet temperature in heating, 0.2–2 K below the mean fluid temperature. The program warns when the lowest inlet temperature falls below the pile minimum (default 0 °C, after SIA D0190 and VDI 4640; Laloui & Rotta Loria 2020 also cite 2 °C), because freezing concrete or ground at the pile can reduce its bearing capacity, and when the highest inlet temperature in cooling exceeds the pile maximum (default 40 °C). Both are warnings for the pile designer to agree, not sizing criteria; sizing keeps the mean fluid temperature limits. The borehole length warning below 20 m does not apply to piles.

Screening. The simulation reports the thermal load on the pile so that it can go to the pile designer. The mean concrete temperature lies midway between the fluid and the pile wall, about where the ring node sits:

Tp=Tf−qRb*2,ΔTp=Tp−Tm
(20.7)

It is taken from the sustained temperatures: the monthly base in monthly mode (the short peaks do not reach the pile as a whole), every hour in the hourly and time-series modes. From the smallest and largest ΔTp of the whole period follow two bounds, with αc the thermal expansion coefficient (default 1.0·10−5 1/K) and Ec the elastic modulus (default 30 GPa) of the concrete:

ε=αcΔTp,ΔL=εH(free pile);σ=EcαcΔTp(fully restrained)
(20.8)

A negative ΔTp (heating) shortens a free pile and puts a restrained pile in tension; a positive one lengthens or compresses it. The real pile lies between the two bounds: its restraint comes from the shaft friction, the toe and the structure on the head, and the axial force and mobilised shaft friction follow from a load-transfer analysis (Bourne-Webb et al. 2009; Amatya et al. 2012; Knellwolf et al. 2011). The screening gives the thermal input of that analysis, not the analysis.

Not available for piles: the dynamic borehole model (its network does not resolve the concrete core) and the 3D finite-element analysis (its mesh couples a borehole as a line, which needs the radius to be small against the mesh cells). Groundwater flow works, also with the adiabatic surface.

20.5 Example: energy piles under a small office

A small office on 24 bored piles of 20 m, diameter 600 mm, on a 4 m grid; a double U-tube 32 × 2.9 mm on the cage; concrete 1.8 W/(m K) and 2.2 MJ/(m³ K); ground 2.0 W/(m K), undisturbed temperature 9.3 °C. About 29 MWh/year heating (seasonal performance factor 3.8) and 12 MWh/year cooling as monthly loads, 25 years, limits 0 / 25 °C. The pile resistance Rb* is 0.0822 m K/W. Table 32 lists the project as delivered and four variants that each change one setting.

Table 32. The energy pile example and four variants.
RunTf,min [°C]Tin,min [°C]ΔTp min / max [K]Restrained σ [MPa]
As delivered: short-time model (ring model), uniform heat flux, isothermal surface3.133.00−3.98 / +2.12−1.19 / +0.63
Steady resistance model2.332.20−3.97 / +2.12−1.19 / +0.64
Energy pile unticked (short-time model with the equivalent pipe)2.942.81––
Uniform wall temperature3.653.52−3.43 / +2.21−1.03 / +0.66
Adiabatic ground surface1.501.36−5.62 / +2.00−1.69 / +0.60

The concrete storage of the ring model raises Tf,min by 0.80 K against the steady model; the equivalent pipe recovers only 0.61 K of it. The uniform wall temperature gives 0.52 K more, which is not conservative; an insulated slab (adiabatic surface) lowers Tf,min by 1.63 K (Figure 19). The screening hardly depends on the borehole model, because it uses the monthly base; it does depend on the ground surface: −5.62 K instead of −3.98 K with the adiabatic surface. For the delivered project the free length change of a 20 m pile is −0.80 mm in heating to +0.42 mm in cooling (strain −40 / +21 µε), and fully restrained −1.19 MPa (tension) to +0.63 MPa (compression). The largest cooling of the pile comes in year 25, because the ground around a heating-dominated field keeps cooling for years; the largest heating comes in year 1, before that drift. The coldest fluid (3.13 °C mean, 3.00 °C at the inlet) is a short peak; the pile as a whole sees the monthly base.

(a) Monthly base mean fluid temperature of the pile field over 25 years with the ring model, the steady model and an adiabatic ground surface (the base temperatures of the ring and the steady model nearly coincide: the concrete storage acts mainly on the short peaks, which set the lowest temperature); (b) the lowest mean fluid temperature of the five runs.
Figure 19. (a) Monthly base mean fluid temperature of the pile field over 25 years with the ring model, the steady model and an adiabatic ground surface (the base temperatures of the ring and the steady model nearly coincide: the concrete storage acts mainly on the short peaks, which set the lowest temperature); (b) the lowest mean fluid temperature of the five runs.

20.6 Verification

20.7 Limits