HomeFeaturesExamplesTutorialsHelpTheoryVerificationPricingContact
Theory manual

29. Heating-system comparison and the coupled heat-pump economics

A ground-source heat pump pays more at the start and less for energy every year. Whether that pays off depends on the period, the interest rate, the tariffs, the maintenance and the residual value of the long-lived borefield, not on the seasonal performance factor alone. The heating-system comparison compares the project's borefield heat pump with an air/water heat pump, gas and oil condensing boilers, a pellet boiler, district heating and an air/water heat pump with a gas peak boiler (hybrid). Every enabled variant must deliver the same useful space heating, hot water and cooling, and each one is reduced to one number: its annual full cost, the annuity of all its discounted cash flows over the period, in the manner of VDI 2067. A ground-source system can lose the comparison.

The example is an office building (about 3000 m²) with monthly loads of 200 MWh/a space heating, 8 MWh/a hot water and 45 MWh/a cooling on a 4 × 4 field of 16 boreholes of 150 m, compared over 20 years at 2 % interest with gross real prices (EUR 2026), the residual value credited, no grant, and the synthetic climate of central Germany (mean 10 °C, amplitude 9 K, design outdoor temperature −12 °C). Tariffs and plant costs of the data set are illustrative values flagged as assumptions.

29.1 Service and energy of each variant

The service comes from the building loads of the project, monthly or hourly; multiyear load tables are averaged to one year, which the economics repeat. Projects with ground loads entered directly cannot be compared, because the useful heat and cold cannot be reconstructed from them. Monthly loads are spread over the hours with the load generator where a variant needs hourly demand.

The synthetic climate is seeded: a seasonal cosine around the annual mean of the climate preset, a daily cycle of ±4 K (warmest at 15 h) and an autocorrelated day-to-day weather with a standard deviation of 3 K. It drives the air/water COP and the heating curve of every heat pump; it is not a test reference year. The energy boundary of a heat pump includes compressor, backup heater and source circulation, so its SPF is the simulated system value; the tabulated JAZ after VDI 4650 Blatt 1:2024 is reported beside it for the heat pump variants (for the borefield with the lowest field outlet temperature as the minimum brine inlet temperature and the simulated source-pump power).

29.2 Investment and operation

The borefield is priced with the cost estimate of the project (simple or detailed, at the current length) and has a service life of 50 years. The plant of every variant is priced at its design power P with the cost curves of the KWW technology catalogue for heat planning, I=aPb (net, for the ground-source heat pump without the borehole source, which the borefield estimate prices), plus the catalogue's additional costs (heating surfaces, buffer, chimney or fuel storage, the district-heating connection) as a separate component. Service lives, repair and servicing fractions and operating hours follow VDI 2067 Blatt 1; the borefield gets 2 % repair and 1 % servicing and inspection per year of its investment. The annual operation of a component is

O=C(fInst+fW+Insp)+hplabour
(29.1)

with the investment C, the two VDI 2067 fractions, the operating hours h and the labour rate (zero for owner-operated residential projects). The fractions apply to the equipment only. Investment entered for a variant is net and is converted to the selected gross or net convention. All defaults are meant to be replaced by local quotations.

29.3 Discounted cash flows, net present value and annuity

With the interest rate i, q=1+i and the period T, the initial investment and a grant are paid at t=0, energy and operation at the end of every year t=1…T, and replacements at kL<T for a component of life L, each discounted at its exact time. The residual value of the last installation, made at tlast, is its unused linear life, credited at t=T:

R=Clastmax(0,L−(T−tlast)L)
(29.2)
NPV=∑tCFtq−t,a=i1−q−T,A=aNPV
(29.3)

Costs are positive, grants and the residual value negative. A is the annual full cost; at i=0, a=1/T. Each cost group (capital, purchased energy, operation, other, grant, residual value) is annualised from its own present value, which gives the split of Figure 25. For an energy price that escalates at a constant rate r the present-value factor of the energy is

b=1−(1+r1+i)Ti−r(i≠r),b=T1+i(i=r)
(29.4)

The yearly cash flows agree with these closed forms, including replacements and residual value, to a relative error below 10−9, and reproduce the published example of VDI 2067 (i = 6 %, r = 2 %, T = 5: a = 0.237, b = 4.374). With energy costs only, the ground-source system breaks even with a boiler at

SPF*=pelηboilerpfuel
(29.5)

which shows why tariffs matter as much as efficiency. The break-even year is the first year after which the discounted cumulative cost of the ground-source system stays below that of the other variant to the end of the period; later replacements can move or remove it, so it is not a simple payback time.

29.4 Prices, carbon and grants

User price anchors are interpolated linearly and held at the nearest end outside their range; without a path, py=p0(1+r)y−y0. Standing charges are applied once per carrier. Prices are real unless nominal prices are selected with consistent paths. For new gas and oil heating the fossil fuel is blended with renewable fuel at the steps of the German building energy law (10 / 15 / 30 / 60 % from 2029 / 2030 / 2035 / 2040), approximated as a fuel share at equal efficiency, and the carbon charge is added separately (retail tariffs must therefore exclude it):

pblend(y)=(1−sy)pfossil(y)+sypbio(y),ΔpCO2(y)=(1−sy)EFpcarbon(y)1000
(29.6)

with the combustion emission factor EF in kg/kWh and the carbon price in €/t (plus VAT in a gross comparison). Low, central and high carbon-price paths are scenarios, not legislated prices; they change only the variants that burn gas or oil. Grants are off by default. They can be a confirmed amount, a user rate and cap, or the dated automatic rules of the German federal funding programmes; the automatic estimate does not check technical, applicant or building eligibility and is assumed to be paid at the start.

29.5 Levelised cost of heat and ecology

LCOHheat=A−AcoldQheat,LCOHheat+cold=AQheat+Qcold,ccold=AcoldQcold
(29.7)

Acold holds the cooling energy and the components allocated to cooling (a chiller, or a cooling fraction of a shared component). Shared costs stay with heat unless allocated, which matters when passive cooling shares the borefield. Two ecological boundaries are reported as annual values at the date of the data set, not as lifetime forecasts: the statutory CO2-equivalent and non-renewable primary energy (compliance metrics of the German building energy law), and an estimate of direct fossil CO2 (grid electricity 0.344 kg/kWh, without upstream emissions, refrigerants and other greenhouse gases; biogenic CO2 counts zero). Qualitative scores with weights (noise, space, permits, drilling risk, price exposure) are a separate judgement; a knock-out removes a variant from the lowest-cost marker, and scores never change the costs.

29.6 Example

Table 64. How the results of the ground-source variant are derived (example office, fixed SPF mode, passive cooling; gross, real prices, EUR).
ResultHow it is derivedExample
Useful heat and coldbuilding loadsheat 208,000 kWh/a (DHW 8,000), cold 45,000 kWh/a
ElectricityCOP at field outlet and heating-curve flow, capacity share, backup, source pump; passive cooling: the pump onlyheating 44,605 kWh/a, cooling 7,297 kWh/a (source pump 13,363 kWh/a in total)
SPF, SEER(27.9)SPF 4.66, SEER 6.17
JAZ after VDI 4650lowest monthly field outlet as minimum brine temperature4.53 (ϑB,min 0.98 °C, FP 1.134)
Investmentplant + additional costs + borefield net total, × (1 + VAT)(60,834 + 41,332 + 131,200) × 1.19 = 277,705 €
Energy costkWh × tariff51,902 kWh × 0.28 €/kWh = 14,533 €/a
Operation(29.1)6,494 €/a
Residual value(29.2)borefield 156,128 × (50 − 20) / 50 = 93,677 € → −3,855 €/a
Annual full cost(29.3)a = 0.0612: 34,154 €/a
LCOH heat / heat + cold / cold(29.7)15.4 / 13.5 / 4.5 ct/kWh
CO2 and primary energykWh × factor of the carrier29.1 t/a statutory, 17.9 t/a direct estimate, 93 MWh/a
Table 65. The variants of the example (20 years, 2 %, gross real prices; data set DE 2026-10 of 2026-10-18).
VariantInvestment [€]Annual full cost [€/a]LCOH heat [ct/kWh]SPF or ηCO2 stat. [t/a]Ground source cheaper from
Ground-source heat pump277,70534,15415.44.6629.1–
Air/water heat pump187,69031,73413.74.4532.5never
Gas condensing boiler65,94140,29916.60.9654.22042
Oil condensing boiler78,38345,29219.00.9376.62039
Pellet boiler133,78535,50214.30.9012.02045
District heating59,30041,03616.90.9845.52040
Hybrid air/water heat pump and gas boiler247,39540,26916.6–36.92039

In this example the air/water heat pump has the lowest annual full cost; the ground-source system costs 2,421 €/a more. By cost group, ground source minus air/water heat pump [€/a]: capital +17, energy −1,719, operation +3,290, residual value +833. The largest difference is the operation: the data set gives the borefield VDI 2067 repair and servicing of 3 % of its investment per year (4,684 €/a here). The ground-source system has the lower energy cost and CO2 and becomes cheaper than gas, oil, pellets, district heating and the hybrid within the period. The default tariffs and plant costs are illustrative: replace them, and review the operation fractions of the borefield, before drawing a conclusion.

Annual full cost of the variants of the example split into the annuities of the cost groups; the residual value is a credit.
Figure 25. Annual full cost of the variants of the example split into the annuities of the cost groups; the residual value is a credit.
Discounted cumulative cost of the variants of the example. Steps up are replacements, the drop in the last year is the residual value.
Figure 26. Discounted cumulative cost of the variants of the example. Steps up are replacements, the drop in the last year is the residual value.

29.7 Coupled heat-pump economics

With fixed seasonal performance factors the borefield temperatures come from the SPF of the loads, while the comparison computes the electricity of the ground-source variant with its own heat pump model from the simulated source temperatures; the two assumptions differ, and a warning says so. In the temperature-dependent mode the ground loads are recomputed from the COP at the simulated field outlet until the energy-weighted SPF changes by less than 0.01 (at most five passes), so the borefield temperatures and the heat-pump electricity are consistent, and the ground-source variant uses the project's heat pump and the borefield sized for it.

Table 66. The ground-source variant with fixed SPF and with the temperature-dependent heat pump and the length sized for it (example office).
Ground-source variantFixed seasonal efficiencyTemperature-dependent
Heat pump in the calculationfixed SPF for the ground loads; default datasheet model of the variantmachine B of the heat pump chapter (2 × 60 kW, minimum brine −8 °C, EER 5.6)
Borehole length, borefield net total150 m, 131,200 €160.0 m, 138,415 €
Coupling passesnone (one pass)3, converged
SPF (simulated) / JAZ (VDI 4650)4.66 / 4.534.71 / 5.13
Electricity [kWh/a]51,90251,984
Annual full cost [€/a]34,15434,748

The plant investment of the variant stays the cost curve of the data set; the quotation of the chosen machine belongs in the variant table. Beyond one comparison the coupling serves three tools: a length sweep of the levelised cost and the SPF against the borehole length, which shows the depth dependence and the temperature-limit boundary; the life-cycle cost objective of the layout optimizer, which ranks thermally sized candidates by their annualised cost with coupled performance (it ranks candidates and does not search a continuous economic optimum over all depths); and Monte Carlo runs on a saved comparison, which carry the uncertainty of building and ground into the SPF and the cost distribution of every variant and give the probability that the ground-source system is the cheapest. That probability is conditional on the input distributions; it does not remove the uncertainty of the model or of its default assumptions.

29.8 Sensitivity

The comparison tabulates a one-at-a-time sensitivity, each case as the annual full cost of the ground-source system minus that of the cheapest other system:

Switching the residual value off shows how much the result rests on the long life of the borefield. Scenario bands are not statistical confidence intervals; if the same explicit carbon path is given to every scenario, the bands coincide.

29.9 Limits