The table summarises how BoreTherm's formulation relates to the conventions of the classic monthly method. Each item was confirmed against the method's published manual and its worked examples, either by the manual's statements or by reproducing the numbers printed there.
| Item | BoreTherm | Classic method | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Undisturbed temperature | (3.2) | same (H/2, no D) | manual; worked example 10.08 °C reproduced |
| Monthly superposition, month-end values, 730 h months | (8.2), (8.3) | same | worked example: 0.08 K rms with D ≈ 4 m |
| Peak pulse at month end, replaces base, energy not added | (8.4) | same | manual |
| Peak g-function | field g (default); (8.5) (option) | asymptote (8.5) | back-calculation, residual ≤ 0.0024 |
| Rb* uniform heat flux | (5.21) (default); fixed Rb* (option) | same; constant values | worked examples; manual's Rb* table ≤ 0.09 % |
| Ra definition | (5.16) | same (2Tf/q12) | Hellström eqs. 8.16–8.21; manual |
| Convection | Gnielinski + blend (default); (5.5) (option) | 4.0 / Colburn (5.5) | worked example; manual's Rp table ≤ 0.1 % |
| Multipole order | J = 3 (0–10) | 1–10 | manual |
| Double-U legs, flow | down-legs adjacent; Re with half the flow | same | manual; Rb* table |
| Sizing period | all years (default); last year (option) | last year | manual; Ahmadfard & Bernier 2019 |
| Hourly peaks | loads as given | last hours of the month | manual |
| Tin/Tout | (8.12) | same (sign converted) | manual |
| g-function | FLS at run time, any layout | library (797 fields, Eskilson SBM) | manual |
Table 68 summarises the measured agreement with published results of the classic monthly method, in BoreTherm's default mode and with the classic-method preset (Section 9.4; the imposed of the Ahmadfard & Bernier cases is set as a fixed effective resistance in both modes). All values were computed with the same BoreTherm version.
| Case | Classic method | BoreTherm default | BoreTherm classic preset |
|---|---|---|---|
| Linden worked example: per pipe [m K/W] | 0.2728 | 0.2890 (+5.9 %) | 0.2727 (−0.04 %) |
| Linden: / [m K/W] | 0.2088 / 0.6625 | 0.2135 / 0.6799 | 0.2088 / 0.6629 (+0.06 %) |
| Linden: at 50 m [m K/W] | 0.2100 | 0.2146 (+2.2 %) | 0.2100 |
| Linden: 48 monthly base , max / rms dev. [K] | – | 0.153 / 0.084 (aligned ) | 0.153 / 0.084 |
| Linden: required length (sizing example) [m] | 82.58 | 82.96 (+0.5 %) | 82.32 (−0.3 %) |
| Manual's against flow, 10 rows, max. dev. | – | 2.1 % | 0.09 % |
| Ahmadfard & Bernier cases 1a–4, 7 lengths | 59.8–123.0 m | within 1.0 % (see note) | within 1.3 % |
| Ahmadfard & Bernier case 3 (10 years) [m] | 87.8 | 110.93 (all years) | 88.87 (+1.2 %) |
| Tutorial example 2 of the manual (Re ≈ 2750) [m] | 129 | 133.98 (+3.9 %) | 128.86 (−0.1 %) |