HomeFeaturesExamplesTutorialsHelpTheoryVerificationPricingContact
BoreTherm / Published referencesReference R1 / R9
Published reference · Sizing

Kavanaugh & Rafferty, Example 3.3: heating-limited field in Ottawa

A heating-dominated office in Ottawa on a 5 × 4 borehole field. BoreTherm sizes the field against the book’s total length and checks three catalogue heat pumps against the result.

2,165 mBoreTherm length, 20 × 108.2 m
2,110 mBook length (p. 73)
+2.6 %Difference in total length
+12.7 %Capacity margin, model 210 × 2
01 / Project

Source, inputs and purpose

Source. Kavanaugh, S. and Rafferty, K. (2014). Geothermal Heating and Cooling: Design of Ground-Source Heat Pump Systems. ASHRAE, Atlanta. Example 3.3, pp. 71–73; design equations of §3.2, pp. 53–56; heat pump data from Table 2.4, p. 30.

Inputs and reference results are taken from the cited publication; BoreTherm results were calculated with BoreTherm on the project rebuilt from those inputs; differences are explained below.

What the example checks

The example sizes a borehole field for a building whose heating load sets the length. It compares BoreTherm’s g-function sizing of the real 5 × 4 field with the ASHRAE design equation, which uses a cylinder source and a tabulated long-term temperature penalty. As an addition that the book does not make, BoreTherm checks three water-to-water units from Table 2.4 against the sized field.

Inputs

Values marked Assumption are not given in the book and were chosen for the BoreTherm project; the others are the book’s, with the section or page.

InputValueSource
Building block loads90 kW heating, 75 kW coolingEx. 3.3
Equivalent full-load hours900 h heating, 450 h coolingEx. 3.3
January part-load factor0.31Ex. 3.3
Heat pump efficiency (fixed)COPh 3.5, COPc 4.8Ex. 3.3
Field5 × 4 boreholes at 6 m spacing, 125 mm diameterEx. 3.3
Boreholesingle U 32 mm DR 11, grout 1.4 W/(m·K)Ex. 3.3
Ground2.0 W/(m·K), diffusivity 0.08 m²/day (2.16 MJ/(m³·K)), 8 °CEx. 3.3
Borehole resistance0.135 m·K/W, imposed as Rb*Ex. 3.3
Fluid and flow20 % propylene glycol, 310 L/min in totalEx. 3.3
Design period and peaks20 years, 4 h peaksEx. 3.3
Length per borehole in the project105.5 m (the book’s 2,110 m over 20 boreholes)p. 73
Sizing criterionmean fluid temperature ≥ −1.5 °C (mean of the entering 0 °C and leaving −3 °C)Assumption
Monthly loadsJanuary 20.76 MWh, other months by an Ottawa degree-day shape; cooling 33.75 MWh/a, May to SeptemberAssumption
Peak months90 kW heating in January, 75 kW cooling in JulyAssumption
Heat pump candidatesmodel 360 (87.0 kW), 2 × model 210 (101.4 kW), 2 × model 180 (89.6 kW) at an entering source of 0 °CTable 2.4, p. 30
Candidate rating sink44 °C leaving (ISO 13256-2 rates at 40 °C entering)Assumption

Run the example in BoreTherm

  1. Open the Ottawa reference project from the examples folder of the installation (File → Open).
  2. Press Size borehole length and open Results → Required borehole length.
  3. Open Design → Heat pump → Selection results and click Check candidates.
02 / How BoreTherm calculates it

Two ways to the length

BookLoads90 kW, 900 h heating;pulses: 20 a, 1 month, 4 hCylinder sourceground resistances of thethree pulsesPenalty−0.5 K from a table+ short-circuit factorLengthdesign equation→ 2,110 m2,110 mBoreThermLoadsmonthly energies + 4 hpeaks, 20 yearsField g-function5 × 4 field at 6 m,interference calculatedSuperpositionTf every month; minimumagainst −1.5 °CSizinglength where TfMin= −1.5 °C → 108.2 m2,165 m (+2.6 %)
The book uses a design equation with a tabulated penalty; BoreTherm calculates the interference of the actual field.
  1. Same loadsBoth start from the 90 kW heating block load and the equivalent full-load hours.
  2. Ground responseThe book uses the cylinder source for three pulses; BoreTherm the g-function of the 20 boreholes.
  3. Long-term interferenceThe book reads −0.5 K from a table; BoreTherm calculates it.
  4. LengthBoth find the length that keeps the fluid at the criterion.
03 / In BoreTherm

The example in BoreTherm

Results → Required borehole length: 108.2 m per borehole.
Results → Required borehole length: 108.2 m per borehole.
Design → Heat pump → Selection results: the three catalogue units checked against the field.
Design → Heat pump → Selection results: the three catalogue units checked against the field.
04 / Results

Calculated results

Displayed values are rounded. Differences are BoreTherm relative to the book unless stated otherwise.

QuantityBookBoreThermDifference
Required total length, heating limited2,110 m2,165 m (20 × 108.2 m)+2.6 %
Same, BoreTherm’s classic-method sizing options2,110 m2,151 m (20 × 107.6 m)+2.0 %
Mean fluid temperature at the book’s 105.5 mcriterion −1.5 °Cminimum −1.74 °C, maximum 18.62 °C0.24 K below the criterion

Heat pump candidates

This check is BoreTherm’s addition; the example itself selects no unit. Requirement: 90 kW at the lowest field outlet temperature, −0.19 °C.

CandidateBook capacity at 0 °C (Table 2.4)BoreTherm capacity lineBoreTherm overall
Model 36087.0 kW−3.3 %, not metNot met
Model 210 × 2101.4 kW+12.7 %, metTight
Model 180 × 289.6 kW−0.4 %, not metNot met
05 / Discussion

Why the results differ

Why the lengths differ

The book sizes with the ASHRAE equation: a cylinder source with three load pulses (20 years, one month, 4 hours), a short-circuit factor and a long-term penalty of −0.5 K read from a table for the field’s spacing. BoreTherm superposes the monthly loads and the peaks on the g-function of the actual 5 × 4 field, so the long-term interference between the boreholes is calculated rather than assumed. At the book’s 105.5 m, BoreTherm’s minimum mean fluid temperature is −1.74 °C, 0.24 K below the criterion, so it asks for 2.6 % more length. Neither the short-circuit factor nor the tabulated penalty is a BoreTherm input; the book’s borehole resistance is imposed as Rb*.

A note on the book’s numbers

The book divides its 2,110 m by 25 boreholes (84 m each), but the stated field has 5 × 4 = 20. The project uses 105.5 m per borehole, which is the book’s total over 20 boreholes.

Heat pump candidates

The capacity margins follow directly from the catalogue values and the 90 kW requirement, so they agree with a hand calculation. The pair of model 210 units meets the capacity requirement but is rated Tight overall for three reasons: its cooling EER (5.0) is only 4.2 % above the 4.8 the ground loads were calculated with; the design source temperature lies 0.19 K below its lowest rating point, so the capacity is extrapolated; and its smallest stage, one unit of 50.7 kW, is above half of the 90 kW peak in a mostly part-load profile. The pair of model 180 units misses the capacity by 0.4 % and the EER by 4.2 %. The flows of Table 2.4 are rating flows, so they are not entered as minimum brine flows.

BoreTherm features exercised