HomeFeaturesExamplesTutorialsHelpTheoryVerificationPricingContact
BoreTherm / Published referencesReference R2 / R9
Published reference · Sizing

Kavanaugh & Rafferty, Chapter 4: cooling-limited field in St. Louis

The north cluster of a St. Louis office on ten boreholes. Cooling sets the length; the heating length is compared as well.

721 mBoreTherm cooling length, 10 × 72.1 m
771 mBook cooling length (p. 110)
−6.5 %Difference, cooling
−7.9 %Difference, heating
01 / Project

Source, inputs and purpose

Source. Kavanaugh, S. and Rafferty, K. (2014). Geothermal Heating and Cooling: Design of Ground-Source Heat Pump Systems. ASHRAE, Atlanta. Chapter 4, §4.2, design steps 1–10, pp. 93–110 (results on p. 110).

Inputs and reference results are taken from the cited publication; BoreTherm results were calculated with BoreTherm on the project rebuilt from those inputs; differences are explained below.

What the example checks

A small cooling-dominated field in a moderate climate. The book designs it step by step with the ASHRAE equation and a tabulated long-term penalty. The comparison shows how BoreTherm’s calculated interference of a 2 × 5 field compares with that penalty, for the cooling length and, separately, for the heating length.

Inputs

Values marked Assumption are not given in the book and were chosen for the BoreTherm project; the others are the book’s, with the section or page.

InputValueSource
Building930 m² office, north cluster of four water-to-air heat pumpspp. 93–99
Block loads35.75 kW cooling, 18.76 kW heatingCh. 4
Heat pump efficiency (fixed)EER 13.8 Btu/Wh (COPc 4.04), COPh 4.0Ch. 4
Equivalent full-load hours, part-load factors890 h cooling, 755 h heating; 0.32 and 0.31Ch. 4
Ground2.25 W/(m·K), diffusivity 0.85 ft²/day (2.46 MJ/(m³·K)), 15 °C (response test)Ch. 4
Borehole130 mm, single U 32 mm DR 11, grout 1.56 W/(m·K)Ch. 4
Borehole resistance0.110 m·K/W, imposed as Rb*Ch. 4
Fluid and flowwater, 117 L/minCh. 4
Design period and peaks20 years, 4 h peaksCh. 4
Length per borehole in the project78 m (the book’s 77.1 m rounded up)p. 110
Field geometry2 × 5 boreholes at 6.1 m (20 ft); the layout is not given in the textAssumption
Sizing criteriamean fluid temperature ≤ 32.8 °C and ≥ 8.3 °C (means of the book’s entering and leaving temperatures)Assumption
Monthly loadsJuly cooling 8.51 MWh, January heating 4.33 MWh; other months by an approximate St. Louis degree-day shapeAssumption
Peak months35.75 kW cooling in July, 18.76 kW heating in JanuaryAssumption

Run the example in BoreTherm

  1. Open the St. Louis reference project from the examples folder (File → Open).
  2. Press Size borehole length and open Results → Required borehole length.
02 / How BoreTherm calculates it

Two ways to the length

BookLoads35.75 kW cooling,890 full-load hoursCylinder sourcethree pulses20 a, 1 month, 4 hPenalty+2.2 K from a table,short circuit 1.04Lengthcooling limited→ 771 m771 mBoreThermLoadsmonthly energies + 4 hpeaks, 20 yearsField g-function2 × 5 at 6.1 m,interference calculatedSuperpositionTf every month against8.3 / 32.8 °CSizingTfMax binding→ 72.1 m721 m (−6.5 %)
For this small field the calculated warming is smaller than the tabulated penalty.
  1. Same loadsThe north cluster's block loads and full-load hours.
  2. Ground responseCylinder source pulses in the book; the g-function of the 2 × 5 field in BoreTherm.
  3. Long-term warming+2.2 K from the table against BoreTherm's calculated warming.
  4. LengthCooling sets the length in both.
03 / In BoreTherm

The example in BoreTherm

Results → Required borehole length: 72.1 m per borehole, limited by the maximum temperature.
Results → Required borehole length: 72.1 m per borehole, limited by the maximum temperature.
04 / Results

Calculated results

Displayed values are rounded. Differences are BoreTherm relative to the book unless stated otherwise.

QuantityBookBoreThermDifference
Cooling length, 10 boreholes771 m (10 × 77.1 m)721 m (10 × 72.1 m)−6.5 %
Same, BoreTherm’s classic-method sizing options771 m716 m (10 × 71.6 m)−7.1 %
Heating length543 m500 m (10 × 50.0 m)−7.9 %
Mean fluid temperature at 78 mcriteria 8.3 / 32.8 °C10.70 / 31.53 °Cwithin both limits
05 / Discussion

Why the results differ

Why BoreTherm is shorter

The book adds a long-term temperature penalty of +2.2 K, read from a table for a 20 ft grid with mild groundwater recharge, and a short-circuit factor of 1.04. BoreTherm calculates the long-term warming of the actual 2 × 5 field from its g-function. For this small, moderately unbalanced field that warming is smaller than the tabulated penalty, so BoreTherm needs 6.5 % less length for cooling.

For heating, the book takes the first year with no annual imbalance and no penalty. In this cooling-dominated field the coldest month is indeed in the first year; BoreTherm still needs 7.9 % less, which reflects the different treatment of the peak and monthly pulses.

What is not compared

The units are water-to-air heat pumps, so BoreTherm’s brine/water candidate check does not apply. The book first designs eight boreholes (766 m) and then redesigns for ten; the comparison uses the ten-borehole design.

BoreTherm features exercised