HomeFeaturesExamplesTutorialsHelpTheoryVerificationPricingContact
BoreTherm / Published referencesReference R3 / R9
Published reference · Sizing

Kavanaugh & Rafferty, Examples 3.2 and 3.5: dense cooling-dominated field in Atlanta

An office in Atlanta rejects far more heat than it extracts. In a dense 5 × 5 field, this is where a calculated long-term interference matters most.

2,670 mBoreTherm length, 25 × 106.8 m
2,438 mBook, iterated (p. 87)
+9.5 %Difference in total length
33.43 °CBoreTherm maximum at the book’s length
01 / Project

Source, inputs and purpose

Source. Kavanaugh, S. and Rafferty, K. (2014). Geothermal Heating and Cooling: Design of Ground-Source Heat Pump Systems. ASHRAE, Atlanta. Example 3.2, pp. 69–71, with the temperature penalty of Example 3.5, pp. 84–87.

Inputs and reference results are taken from the cited publication; BoreTherm results were calculated with BoreTherm on the project rebuilt from those inputs; differences are explained below.

What the example checks

A strongly cooling-dominated building on a closely spaced field. The book first assumes a small long-term penalty, then calculates it and iterates the length. The comparison checks BoreTherm’s field interference where the ground warms year after year.

Inputs

Values marked Assumption are not given in the book and were chosen for the BoreTherm project; the others are the book’s, with the section or page.

InputValueSource
Block loads300,000 Btu/h cooling (87.92 kW), 180,000 Btu/h heating (52.75 kW)Ex. 3.2
August part-load factor0.28Ex. 3.2
Heat pump efficiency (fixed)EER 14.1 Btu/Wh (COPc 4.13), COPh 4.1Ex. 3.2
Equivalent full-load hours1,220 h cooling, 590 h heatingEx. 3.2
Field5 × 5 boreholes at 20 ft (6.1 m), 127 mm, 1 in. DR 11 single UEx. 3.2
Ground2.42 W/(m·K), diffusivity 1.0 ft²/day (2.25 MJ/(m³·K)), 18.33 °CEx. 3.2
Grout1.73 W/(m·K)Ex. 3.2
Fluid and flowwater, 2.98 gpm per U-tube (4.70 L/s in total)Ex. 3.2
Borehole resistance0.104 m·K/W, imposed as Rb*Ex. 3.2
Design period10 yearsEx. 3.2
Length per borehole in the project97.5 m (the book’s iterated 320 ft)p. 87
Sizing criterionmean fluid temperature ≤ 32.22 °C (90 °F, mean of the entering 85 °F and leaving 95 °F)Assumption
Monthly loadsAugust cooling 18.32 MWh, the rest of the year by an office shape; heating by approximate Atlanta degree daysAssumption
Peak months87.92 kW cooling in August, 52.75 kW heating in January, 4 hAssumption

Run the example in BoreTherm

  1. Open the Atlanta reference project from the examples folder (File → Open).
  2. Press Calculate to see the temperatures at the book's 97.5 m.
  3. Press Size borehole length and open Results → Required borehole length.
02 / How BoreTherm calculates it

Two ways to the length

BookLoads87.9 kW cooling,1,220 full-load hoursPenaltyassumed, then calculatedfrom ring temperaturesIteratelength ↔ penalty≈ 2.8 KLength10 years→ 2,438 m≈ 2,438 mBoreThermLoadsmonthly energies + 4 hpeaks, 10 yearsField g-function5 × 5 at 6.1 m, dense:B/H ≈ 0.06Superposition110 MWh/a net into theground, year after yearSizingTfMax 32.22 °C→ 106.8 m2,670 m (+9.5 %)
In a dense, strongly unbalanced field the calculated interference exceeds the book's penalty.
  1. Same loadsThe block loads, full-load hours and efficiencies of Example 3.2.
  2. PenaltyThe book iterates a long-term penalty from ring temperatures.
  3. Field responseBoreTherm's g-function of the 25 boreholes includes all interaction.
  4. LengthCooling sets the length in both.
03 / In BoreTherm

The example in BoreTherm

Results → Mean fluid temperature at the book's 97.5 m: the maximum exceeds 32.2 °C.
Results → Mean fluid temperature at the book's 97.5 m: the maximum exceeds 32.2 °C.
Results → Required borehole length: 106.8 m per borehole.
Results → Required borehole length: 106.8 m per borehole.
04 / Results

Calculated results

Displayed values are rounded. Differences are BoreTherm relative to the book unless stated otherwise.

QuantityBookBoreThermDifference
Cooling length, iterated penalty (Ex. 3.5)≈ 2,438 m (25 × 320 ft)2,670 m (25 × 106.8 m)+9.5 %
Same, BoreTherm’s classic-method sizing options≈ 2,438 m2,658 m (25 × 106.3 m)+9.0 %
Cooling length with the assumed penalty of 2 °F2,141 m (p. 71)2,670 m+24.7 %
Maximum mean fluid temperature at 97.5 mcriterion 32.22 °C33.43 °C1.2 K above the criterion
Cooling length over 20 instead of 10 years–2,923 m (25 × 116.9 m)+20 % against 2,438 m
05 / Discussion

Why the results differ

Why BoreTherm is longer here

About 110 MWh of net heat goes into the ground every year, into a field whose spacing is only about 6 % of its depth. The book’s calculated penalty (about 2.8 K, plus about 0.8 K from the annual load through the ground resistance) underestimates the rise in ground temperature that the field’s g-function gives over ten years. In the two moderately unbalanced Kavanaugh cases (Ottawa and St. Louis) BoreTherm is within −8 % to +3 % of the book; in this strongly unbalanced case it is the longer design. This is the clearest example in the series of why computing the interference, instead of taking a tabulated penalty, changes the answer.

Notes on the book’s numbers

BoreTherm features exercised