Source, inputs and purpose
Source. Chiasson, A.D. (2016). Geothermal Heat Pump and Heat Engine Systems: Theory and Practice. Wiley / ASME Press. §6.5.2: Example 6.5, pp. 212–213, and Example 6.6, pp. 213–214; input sheet Fig. 6.12 (p. 206), monthly loads Fig. 6.14 (p. 208), heat pump curve Fig. 4.22 (p. 130).
Inputs and reference results are taken from the cited publication; BoreTherm results were calculated with BoreTherm on the project rebuilt from those inputs; differences are explained below.
What the example checks
A larger, heating-dominated field (about 4 : 1) sized from monthly energies and monthly peak loads. The comparison shows how two treatments of the peaks and of the heat pump efficiency affect the length, and how a limit on the heat pump entering temperature translates to BoreTherm’s criterion on the mean fluid temperature.
Inputs
Values marked Assumption are not given in the book and were chosen for the BoreTherm project; the others are the book’s, with the section or page.
| Input | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Field | 6 × 8 = 48 boreholes at 6 m, 127 mm | Fig. 6.12 |
| Ground | 2.0 W/(m·K), 2,200 kJ/(m³·K), 12 °C | Fig. 6.12 |
| Borehole resistance | 0.15 m·K/W, imposed as Rb* | Fig. 6.12 |
| Fluid | specific heat 3.90 kJ/(kg·K), 432 L/min in total | Fig. 6.12 |
| Loads | heating 263.0 MWh/a, cooling 64.8 MWh/a; peaks 144 kW and 70 kW, 6 h each month | Fig. 6.14 |
| Heat pump curve | heating COP 3.00 / 3.73 / 4.46 at 0 / 10 / 20 °C entering | Fig. 4.22 |
| Design period | 20 years from January | Ex. 6.5 |
| Limits on the heat pump entering temperature | 0 °C and 30 °C | Ex. 6.5 |
| Efficiency | fixed seasonal performance factor 3.5 heating, 5.5 cooling (the book recomputes the ground loads from the curve each month) | Assumption |
| Sizing criteria | mean fluid temperature ≥ −1.78 °C and ≤ 31.43 °C, converted from the entering-temperature limits with the book’s Eq. 6.8 (p. 194) at the largest peaks | Assumption |
| Fluid properties | density 1,030 kg/m³, viscosity 4 mPa·s, freezing point −10 °C (only the heat capacity flow matters with an imposed resistance) | Assumption |
Run the example in BoreTherm
- Open the 6 × 8 reference project from the examples folder (File → Open).
- Press Size borehole length; Results → Required borehole length lists the inlet and outlet temperatures at the sized length.
- For Example 6.6, set the length to 90 m and press Calculate.
Two ways to the length
- Same loadsMonthly energies and monthly 6-hour peaks of Fig. 6.14.
- EfficiencyThe book recomputes the ground loads from the heat pump curve every month; BoreTherm uses a fixed seasonal factor.
- PeaksLine source in the book, the field g-function in BoreTherm.
- CriterionThe book limits the entering temperature; BoreTherm the mean fluid temperature, converted with the book's own relation.
The example in BoreTherm
Calculated results
Displayed values are rounded. Differences are BoreTherm relative to the book unless stated otherwise.
| Quantity | Book | BoreTherm | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ex. 6.5: required total length, heating limited | 4,661 m (48 × 97.1 m) | 4,083 m (48 × 85.1 m) | −12.4 % |
| Same, BoreTherm’s classic-method sizing options | 4,661 m | 4,075 m (48 × 84.9 m) | −12.6 % |
| Lowest field outlet (the book’s entering temperature) at the sized length | limit 0 °C | −0.07 °C | supports the limit conversion |
| Sensitivity: fixed heating SPF 3.0 / 3.73 instead of 3.5 | 4,661 m | 3,715 / 4,218 m | −20 % / −9.5 % |
| Ex. 6.6: the field drilled to 90 m | entering temperature slightly below 0 °C near year 20 | mean fluid −1.13 °C in year 20 (limit −1.78 °C), lowest outlet +0.57 °C | BoreTherm: still within the limit |
Why the results differ
Why BoreTherm is shorter
Two modelling choices differ. The book superposes each month’s 6-hour peak as a line source on top of the monthly steps, while BoreTherm uses the field g-function for the peaks as well. The book also recalculates the ground loads every month from the heat pump curve, so the extraction rises as the entering temperature falls. BoreTherm uses a fixed seasonal performance factor here. The value 3.5 is the one implied by the book’s own 20-year heat pump energy (1.750 × 10⁶ kWh, p. 213). Fixed values of 3.0 and 3.73, the curve at 0 °C and 10 °C, bracket the result between −20 % and −9.5 %. The size and direction of the difference are similar to the moderate Kavanaugh cases.
Entering temperature against mean fluid temperature
The book states its limits on the heat pump entering temperature, which is the field outlet. BoreTherm sizes on the mean fluid temperature, so the project converts the limits with the book’s own relation between the two at the largest peaks. At the sized length BoreTherm’s lowest field outlet is −0.07 °C, next to the book’s 0 °C, which supports the conversion.