Source, inputs and purpose
Source. Kavanaugh, S. and Rafferty, K. (2014). Geothermal Heating and Cooling: Design of Ground-Source Heat Pump Systems. ASHRAE, Atlanta. Example 6.1, pp. 183–185, with its head-loss sheet Table 6.1 (p. 184) and the pump power benchmarks of Table 6.2 (p. 185).
Inputs and reference results are taken from the cited publication; BoreTherm results were calculated with BoreTherm on the project rebuilt from those inputs; differences are explained below.
What the example checks
The pressure drop in the borehole loops for an antifreeze at low temperature, where the flow is in the transition range, and how it adds up with the header, valves, hoses, strainer and heat pump coil to the pump head.
Inputs
Values marked Assumption are not given in the book and were chosen for the BoreTherm project; the others are the book’s, with the section or page.
| Input | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Heat pump | 5 ton (18 kW) at 15 gpm (57 L/min) | Ex. 6.1 |
| U-tubes | five ¾ in. DR 11 U-tubes of 250 ft (76.2 m) in parallel, 3 gpm each | Ex. 6.1 |
| Fluid | 20 % propylene glycol at 40 °F (4.4 °C), 1,025 kg/m³, 3.44 cP | Ex. 6.1 |
| Header, valves, hose kits, strainer | 19.1 ft = 58.5 kPa, entered as the header pressure drop | Table 6.1 |
| Heat pump coil | 12.6 ft = 38.6 kPa at 15 gpm, entered as the candidate’s evaporator pressure drop | Table 6.1 |
| Revised design | 1 in. U-tubes, 243 ft | p. 184 |
| Fluid conductivity, specific heat, freezing point | 0.47 W/(m·K), 3,930 J/(kg·K), −7 °C | Assumption |
| Field and thermal side | five boreholes in a line at 6.1 m; ground and loads of the St. Louis example scaled to 5 tons (they only illustrate) | Assumption |
| Candidate rating | 17.58 kW, COP 4.0 (the unit is water-to-air; only its pump head line is used) | Assumption |
Run the example in BoreTherm
- Open the unitary loop reference project from the examples folder (File → Open).
- Press Calculate: Design → Fluid & flow and the Results summary list the Reynolds number and the loop pressure drop.
- Open Design → Heat pump → Selection results and click Check candidates for the pump head.
How the pump head adds up
- Flow per loop15 gpm over five parallel U-tubes.
- ReynoldsEqual to the book's 3,290.
- FrictionThe friction factor of the transition range.
- Loop lossTwice the borehole length; the book adds 8 ft for the U-bend.
- Header + coilEntered as the header pressure drop and the candidate's evaporator pressure drop.
- Pump headThe sum is the head the pump must deliver.
The example in BoreTherm
Calculated results
Displayed values are rounded. Differences are BoreTherm relative to the book unless stated otherwise.
| Quantity | Book | BoreTherm | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| U-tube Reynolds number | 3,290 | 3,290 | 0 |
| U-tube loop, 500 ft | 13.5 ft = 41.4 kPa printed; 40.1 kPa from the book’s gradient over 508 ft | 38.8 kPa | −6.3 % / −3.4 % |
| Header, valves, hoses, strainer | 58.5 kPa | input | – |
| Coil | 38.6 kPa | input | – |
| Total pump head | 45.2 ft = 138.5 kPa | 135.9 kPa | −1.9 % |
| Revised design: 1 in. U-tubes, 243 ft | 3.8 ft = 11.6 kPa | 13.1 kPa (Reynolds number 2,629) | +13 % |
| Pump grade (input power per kW of load) | 43 W/kW, grade F | not a BoreTherm output | – |
Why the results differ
Why the loop loss differs
The book counts the U-bend as 8 ft of extra pipe (508 ft per loop). BoreTherm’s loop pressure drop covers twice the borehole length only, 500 ft. Most of the remaining difference to the printed 13.5 ft is a rounding in the book: its own gradient of 2.57 ft per 100 ft over 508 ft gives 13.1 ft, and the text quotes 39 kPa. The total pump head differs by 1.9 %.
The revised design
With 1 in. U-tubes the Reynolds number drops to about 2,630, in the transition range; the book calls the flow non-laminar. BoreTherm’s friction factor in the transition is higher than the book’s turbulent value, so it gives 13 % more for the revised loops.
What is not compared
The book grades the design by the pump input power per kW of load (43 W/kW, grade F, for two 385 W pumps on 18 kW). BoreTherm has no pump-grade output, and its pump power covers the field pressure drop only. The coil’s pressure drop scaled to 3.2 l/min per kW (37.9 kPa) is just above the 35 kPa guide value (Kavanaugh and Rafferty 2014, p. 223), so BoreTherm rates that line Tight.
BoreTherm features exercised
- Hydraulics and pressure drop
- Heat carrier fluids
- Heat pump selection: header and evaporator pressure drops in the brine pump head