HomeFeaturesExamplesTutorialsHelpTheoryVerificationPricingContact
BoreTherm / Published referencesReference R9 / R9
Published reference · Energy piles

Laloui & Rotta Loria, problem 14.xx: an energy pile under eight months of heating

One representative energy pile, 0.8 m in diameter and 19.2 m long, extracts heat for eight months. The fluid temperature change is compared with the book’s infinite line and cylinder sources.

−9.05 KBoreTherm fluid temperature change
−9.8 / −10.0 KBook: line / cylinder source
0.75–0.95 KBoreTherm milder
1.95 °CLowest fluid temperature (limit 1 °C)
01 / Project

Source, inputs and purpose

Source. Laloui, L. and Rotta Loria, A.F. (2020). Analysis and Design of Energy Geostructures. Academic Press. Chapter 14, problem 14.xx: statement pp. 910–913, solution pp. 926–931.

Inputs and reference results are taken from the cited publication; BoreTherm results were calculated with BoreTherm on the project rebuilt from those inputs; differences are explained below.

What the example checks

A short, wide heat exchanger: an energy pile with an aspect ratio of 24. The comparison checks how the finite length of the pile changes the temperature after a season, compared with the infinite line and cylinder sources used in preliminary energy pile design.

Inputs

Values marked Assumption are not given in the book and were chosen for the BoreTherm project; the others are the book’s, with the section or page.

InputValueSource
Pile0.8 m diameter, 19.2 m mean length (one of 162 piles)pp. 910–913
Ground (response test)T0 11 °C, 1.5 W/(m·K), diffusivity 6.4 × 10⁻⁷ m²/s (2.34 MJ/(m³·K))pp. 910–913
Pile resistance0.11 m·K/W, imposed as Rb*p. 928
Criterionsoil at least 1 °C, a fluid temperature change of at least −10 Kp. 912
Design extraction rate−25.3 W/m for eight months of 29.5 daysp. 929
Load in the project−25.3 W/m × 19.2 m = 485.8 W of direct ground load, hourly, for 5,664 h, then no load; 1 yearfrom p. 929
Pile head and boundary conditionat the ground surface; uniform heat transfer rate set explicitly; cylindrical correction onAssumption
Pipes, concrete, fluiddouble U 32 × 2.9 mm, concrete 1.8 W/(m·K), 25 % propylene glycol at 12 L/min (no effect with the imposed resistance)Assumption
Not modelledthe pile group (spacing not given), the soil layers and the groundwater flow (the book does not use them either)Assumption

Run the example in BoreTherm

  1. Open the energy pile reference project from the examples folder (File → Open).
  2. Press Calculate and open Results → Hourly temperatures.
  3. For other extraction rates, scale the heating load on the Loads page (or with --set loads.heatingScale on the command line).
02 / How BoreTherm calculates it

Finite pile against infinite sources

BookLoad−25.3 W/m for8 monthsInfinite sourceline or cylinder,pile isolatedResistance+ q R′ with0.11 m·K/WΔT fluid−9.8 K (line)−10.0 K (cylinder)−9.8 / −10.0 KBoreThermLoad485.8 W hourly,5,664 h, then offFinite line source19.2 m pile: heat alsoflows around its endsCylinder correctionwide pile (0.8 m)+ q Rb* 0.11ΔT fluidafter 8 months→ −9.05 K−9.05 K, 0.95 K to spare
The finite length of the short pile makes the result milder than the infinite sources.
  1. Same load−25.3 W/m over 19.2 m for eight months.
  2. Ground responseThe infinite sources ignore the pile's ends; the finite line source includes them (about 11 % less after eight months).
  3. Pile radiusThe cylindrical correction accounts for the 0.8 m diameter.
  4. FluidThe resistance term qR′ is added in both.
03 / In BoreTherm

The example in BoreTherm

Design → Borehole cross-section: the energy pile option.
Design → Borehole cross-section: the energy pile option.
Results → Hourly temperatures: eight months of extraction, then recovery.
Results → Hourly temperatures: eight months of extraction, then recovery.
04 / Results

Calculated results

Displayed values are rounded. Differences are BoreTherm relative to the book unless stated otherwise.

Change of the mean fluid temperature at the end of the load period. Book: infinite line source plus qR′ / cylinder source.

QuantityBookBoreThermDifference
−25.3 W/m for 8 months (design rate)−9.8 / −10.0 K−9.05 K0.75 / 0.95 K milder
−30 W/m for 8 months−11.6 / −11.8 K−10.73 K0.87 / 1.07 K milder
+30 W/m for 4 months+10.5 / +10.8 K+9.97 K0.53 / 0.83 K milder
−21.3 W/m for 8 months (final design)−8.4 / −8.4 K−7.62 K0.78 K milder
05 / Discussion

Why the results differ

Why BoreTherm is milder

The book treats every pile as an isolated infinite line or cylinder source. A 19.2 m pile is short compared with the distance heat travels in eight months, so heat also flows around its ends; after eight months the finite line source is about 11 % below the infinite one. BoreTherm’s result equals the finite line source plus the cylinder correction plus qR′, which an independent calculation reproduces (−9.05 K). The design criterion is met with 0.95 K to spare.

Boundary condition

For a pile whose head is at the ground surface, the project sets the uniform heat transfer rate condition explicitly. With BoreTherm’s default uniform borehole wall temperature, this short pile gives −7.78 K, a milder and therefore non-conservative value.

Notes on the book’s numbers

What is not modelled

A pile group would be colder: after eight months the thermal reach is about 7 m, and the pile spacing is not given. Like the book, the project ignores the soil layers and the groundwater flow of 0.2 m/day.

BoreTherm features exercised