HomeFeaturesExamplesTutorialsHelpTheoryVerificationPricingContact
BoreTherm / Published referencesReference R6 / R9
Published reference · Borehole resistance

Chiasson, Examples 5.4b to 5.6: borehole thermal resistance

Four single-U configurations: two grouts and two pipe positions. BoreTherm’s multipole resistance is compared with the book’s result sheets.

0.1799BoreTherm Rb [m·K/W], Ex. 5.4b
0.1802Book Rb [m·K/W], Ex. 5.4b
≤ 0.4 %Largest difference, four cases
20,457Reynolds number (book 20,453)
01 / Project

Source, inputs and purpose

Source. Chiasson, A.D. (2016). Geothermal Heat Pump and Heat Engine Systems: Theory and Practice. Wiley / ASME Press. §5.5.6: Example 5.4b, pp. 164–166, with its result sheet Fig. E.5.4b (p. 166); Example 5.5 a–c, p. 167; Example 5.6, pp. 167–169, with Fig. E.5.6 (p. 168).

Inputs and reference results are taken from the cited publication; BoreTherm results were calculated with BoreTherm on the project rebuilt from those inputs; differences are explained below.

What the example checks

The local borehole resistance, from the fluid to the borehole wall, of a single U-tube: the base case, a better grout, the legs moved against the borehole wall, and both. This is the quantity that connects the fluid temperature to the ground model, so it is checked on its own.

Inputs

Values marked Assumption are not given in the book and were chosen for the BoreTherm project; the others are the book’s, with the section or page.

InputValueSource
PipeDN25 SDR 11 HDPE: outer 33.401 mm, inner 27.328 mm, 0.4 W/(m·K)Fig. E.5.4b
Leg position, Ex. 5.4bevenly spaced, 31.75 mm from the borehole centre (shank spacing 63.5 mm)Fig. E.5.4b
Borehole127 mm, 75 mFig. E.5.4b
Fluid and flowwater at 5 °C, 40 L/minFig. E.5.4b
Grout and groundgrout 0.73 W/(m·K), ground 1.8 W/(m·K)pp. 166–167
Ex. 5.5 a / b / cgrout 1.50 W/(m·K) / legs against the borehole wall (shank spacing 93.6 mm) / bothp. 167
Resistance modelmultipole, order 3Assumption
Depth, ground heat capacity and temperature, loadsillustrative only; the local resistance does not depend on themAssumption

Run the example in BoreTherm

  1. Open the single-U resistance reference project from the examples folder (File → Open).
  2. Open Design → Borehole cross-section; the resistance panel updates as you change the grout or the shank spacing.
  3. Press Parametric study to run the stored study of the four cases.
02 / How BoreTherm calculates it

The resistance chain of Example 5.4b

1 Water at 5 °C40 L/min in DN25 SDR 11→ Re 20,4572 ConvectionNu 180.7→ h 3,772 W/(m²·K)3 Pipe resistancewall 0.4 W/(m·K)+ film → Rp 0.0834 Multipoleorder 3, grout 0.73,ground 1.8 W/(m·K)5 Rbfluid to borehole wall0.1799 m·K/WRb 0.1799 m·K/W (book 0.1802)
The local borehole resistance of the single U, as on the Borehole cross-section page.
  1. Flow regimeThe Reynolds number agrees with the book's sheet (20,453).
  2. ConvectionThe heat transfer coefficient at the pipe wall.
  3. Pipe resistanceConduction through the HDPE wall plus the convection film.
  4. MultipoleConduction in the grout between the two legs and the borehole wall.
  5. RbWithin 0.4 % of the book in all four cases.
03 / In BoreTherm

The example in BoreTherm

Design → Borehole cross-section: the single U of Example 5.4b with the live resistance.
Design → Borehole cross-section: the single U of Example 5.4b with the live resistance.
04 / Results

Calculated results

Displayed values are rounded. Differences are BoreTherm relative to the book unless stated otherwise.

Local borehole resistance Rb in m·K/W.

QuantityBookBoreThermDifference
Ex. 5.4b: base case0.18020.1799−0.2 %
Ex. 5.5a: grout 1.50 W/(m·K)0.11200.1116−0.4 %
Ex. 5.5b: legs against the wall0.12420.1239−0.2 %
Ex. 5.5c: both0.09020.0898−0.4 %
Reynolds number, Ex. 5.4b20,45320,4570.0 %
05 / Discussion

Why the results differ

Single U: the validation

Both the book’s tool and BoreTherm use a multipole-type borehole resistance, and they agree within 0.4 % in all four single-U cases. The three variants of Example 5.5 are stored in the project as a parametric study (grout conductivity × shank spacing), so all four values come from one run. With the line-source approximation (multipole order 0) BoreTherm’s values are 0.4–3.5 % higher.

A note on the book’s inputs

The text of Example 5.4b gives a 125 mm borehole and 10 L/min, but its result sheet and its result use 127 mm and 40 L/min; the book’s 0.1802 is reproduced only with the sheet’s inputs. With 10 L/min BoreTherm gives 0.1846 m·K/W at a Reynolds number of 5,114.

Double U (Example 5.6): an inconsistency in the book

The double-U example is not presented as a match. The book’s 0.086 m·K/W is an effective resistance (its Eq. 5.39, p. 162, includes the short-circuit term between the legs), not the local resistance compared above. Its definition of the pipe spacing is ambiguous (between pipe edges or between centres), and its grout term looks too small. BoreTherm’s effective Rb* and local Rb will be documented against the 0.086 m·K/W.

Double U, Example 5.6: an inconsistency in the book, not a validation point. The book’s 0.086 m·K/W is an effective resistance (its Eq. 5.39, p. 162): a grout term of 0.034 plus a short-circuit term of 0.052 computed with the flow of a single U-tube. That grout term is far too small for the stated geometry: a line-source calculation with the book’s own pipe resistance gives about 0.14, and the multipole method (BoreTherm and an independent open-source library agree to five digits) gives 0.142. The book also describes the 75 mm spacing both as centre-to-centre and as between pipe edges.
Reading of the 75 mm spacingLocal Rb [m·K/W]Effective Rb* [m·K/W]Rb* vs book 0.086
Centre-to-centre, opposite legs (as stated; used in the project)0.14190.1517+76 %
Centre-to-centre, adjacent legs0.08780.0969+13 %
Between pipe edges, opposite legs0.08410.0932+8 %

Whichever reading is taken, the book’s value cannot be reproduced from its own inputs, so the double U is shown here for transparency only. The single-U results above are the validation.

BoreTherm features exercised