1.1 Purpose and scope
This reference documents the physical models, equations and numerical methods of BoreTherm, a desktop tool for designing fields of vertical borehole heat exchangers (BHE) for ground-source heat pumps. It is written for engineers who check the results or build on the methods, and for reviewers who need to trace a result back to its equation. The operation of the program is not described here.
BoreTherm computes, for a given borehole field, heat exchanger and load:
- the thermal response factor (g-function) of the field, for any layout of vertical or inclined boreholes, in homogeneous or layered ground, with or without groundwater flow;
- the borehole thermal resistances , and , and the pipe hydraulics;
- the mean fluid temperature over 1 to 100 years, month by month with peak loads, or hour by hour;
- the borehole length needed to keep the fluid temperature within limits (sizing);
- the cheapest or shortest layout on a given plot or inside a site plan with no-go zones (optimization);
- the effect of uncertain inputs (parametric studies, Monte Carlo) and the ground properties from a thermal response test.
1.2 Relation to the classic monthly method
BoreTherm follows the classic monthly method of borehole design (Hellström & Sanner 1994): temporal superposition of g-function step responses with monthly base loads, a rectangular peak pulse at the end of every month, equal 730-hour months, Hellström's effective borehole resistance and the multipole method. The classic monthly conventions were checked against the method's published manual and by reproducing the numbers of its worked examples; the evidence is summarised in Appendix A. Where BoreTherm deliberately differs from the classic conventions, the difference is stated and, where useful, a compatibility option exists (Section 1.4).
The main methodological difference is the g-function. The classic method interpolates in a library of about 800 pre-computed configurations obtained with Eskilson's numerical model (vertical boreholes, = 0.02–0.5, regular layouts only). BoreTherm computes the g-function of the actual field at run time with the semi-analytical finite line source method of Cimmino & Bernier (2014), so irregular layouts, unequal lengths and any spacing are handled directly.
1.3 What BoreTherm adds
- g-functions for any layout: uniform heat rate or uniform borehole-wall temperature, with the similarities and equivalent-borehole accelerations (Chapter 4).
- Hourly simulation: exact temporal superposition by FFT convolution, or Claesson–Javed load aggregation, with inlet and outlet temperatures (Section 8.3).
- Hydraulics: friction factor, pressure drop and pump power (Section 5.8).
- Temperature-dependent fluid properties for water and aqueous MEG, MPG and ethanol (Chapter 6).
- Fast sizing with an interpolating g-function cache and exact confirmation (Section 9.3), and an optimizer that enumerates layouts on a plot with a cost model and a minimum-spanning-tree trench estimate (Section 9.5).
- Layered ground: horizontal layers with effective properties over the active length and two models of the undisturbed temperature (Section 3.3); a segmented model that gives each layer its own properties in the g-function, borehole sections with finite insulation and the uniform-fluid-temperature boundary condition (Chapter 11).
- Groundwater flow with the moving finite line source, uniform or per layer (Chapter 12).
- Inclined boreholes up to 85° and fields of unequal boreholes (Chapter 13).
- Borehole connection networks: strings in series, equal-flow or equal-pressure-drop split, string temperatures (Chapter 14).
- Short-time borehole model with the heat capacity of fluid, pipes and grout, and TRCM parameters for dynamic models (Chapter 15).
- Site plans from drawings (DXF) with drilling areas, no-go zones and setbacks, fill patterns and the optimization inside the site (Chapter 16).
- Thermal response test evaluation: line-source slope, parameter estimation with superposition, moving line source, recovery, identifiability checks and Monte Carlo uncertainty, with the result written into the design (Chapter 17).
- Parametric studies and Monte Carlo analyses over any registered input: full grids, one-at-a-time sensitivity, Latin-hypercube sampling, percentiles of the required length and rank-correlation sensitivity (Chapter 10).
- Reports in PDF, HTML and Markdown, interactively, automatically after a calculation, or for many projects at once; the program and the reports in English and German.
1.4 Compatibility options for the classic monthly method
Four options reproduce the conventions of the classic monthly method where they differ from BoreTherm's defaults. Every default keeps BoreTherm's behaviour. The options are stored with the project (a project without them gets the defaults) and can be set in the program.
| Option | Default / classic | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| Fixed effective resistance | 0 (computed) / > 0 | Constant at every length (the classic “constant values”); , and the hydraulics are still computed (Section 5.7). |
| Convection model | Gnielinski / classic | Nu = 4.0 laminar, turbulent, no transition blend (Section 5.2). |
| Peak response | field g-function / asymptote | Peak pulses use Eskilson's single-borehole asymptote instead of the field g-function (Section 8.2). |
| Last year only | off / on | Sizing checks the limits in the last simulated year only (Section 9.4). |
The classic-method preset sets the convection, the peak response and last-year sizing to the classic monthly conventions; the formula and the UBWT g-function follow the classic conventions already by default, and a fixed is a separate input. With the preset BoreTherm reproduces the borehole resistances printed in the method's published manual to 0.06 % and the required lengths of seven published cases computed with the classic method to 1.3 % (Table 68 in Appendix A).
1.5 Document conventions
Equations are numbered by chapter. Symbols are listed in Chapter 2. Units are SI unless stated; temperatures are in °C. The numerical examples use the ground, borehole and fluid of the program's example project: = 2.6 W/(m K), = 2.2 MJ/(m³ K), H = 150 m, = 70 mm, D = 4 m, B = 6 m, single-U PE 32 × 2.9 mm, 25 % monopropylene glycol at 0.5 l/s per borehole. All numbers in this manual were computed with BoreTherm.
Chapters 1–10 describe the method BoreTherm shares with the classic monthly method and its classical extensions. Chapters 11–17 describe the further models: the segmented layered model with borehole sections, groundwater flow, inclined and unequal boreholes, connection networks, the short-time borehole model, site plans and the evaluation of thermal response tests. Chapter 18 to Chapter 29 describe the dynamic borehole model, borehole thermal energy storage, energy piles, the thermal plume, the finite element models, co-simulation, the load tools and input checks, the heat pump, the borefield costs and the heating-system comparison. Each of the extensions reduces exactly to the classical model when it is not used: a project that does not use one of these features gives bit-identical results.